Buying Guides

Atlas vs. Crema Coffee Subscription Review

While Atlas Coffee Club and Crema Coffee both have a wide variety of coffee, Atlas Coffee chooses what coffee is sent to you, and Crema Coffee lets you curate your own list of coffee deliveries.


Just so you know, if you click on a product on RoastyCoffee.com and decide to buy it, we may earn a small commission.

It’s always fun to experience new things, especially when it comes to coffee. That’s why we always rave about our favorite coffee subscription services. With all of the choices, there are so many ways you can go about getting your coffee fixed.

We found two subscriptions, though, that work hard to make sure you can find new coffee that you’ll love. Atlas Coffee Club and Crema Coffee make ordering coffee fun, each in its own way!

atlas vs crema coffee

What is Atlas Coffee Club?

Atlas Coffee Club Subscription
ATLAS COFFEE CLUB
  • A curation of the world’s best single origin coffee
  • Coffee & postcard from a new country each month
  • Tasting notes & brewing tips for each batch
  • Your personalized preferences, on your schedule
Check Price

Atlas Coffee Club is a coffee subscription box that prides itself on only serving premium single-origin coffee beans. Based on your coffee preferences, each bag of delicious coffee they choose for you is roasted to order.

Atlas Coffee Club Subscription

This choice can be fun for coffee lovers because each delivery comes with a postcard from the country of origin, tasting notes, and tips to help you bring out the flavor of the coffee you receive.

Atlas also provides an online coffee passport where you can keep track of all the countries you get coffee from and earn points for doing so. The best thing is that Atlas only sends you coffee that’s in the top one percent!

Like Free Coffee? Get your first bag free with an Atlas Coffee World Tour Click here to get the deal

What is Crema Coffee?

Crema Coffee’s subscription service really strives to educate the coffee-drinking community through its wide selection of fresh coffee blends. Freshness is guaranteed thanks to their large variety of coffee roasters, who make sure it’s roasted right before it’s shipped to you.

Crema Coffee subscription

The “try it free” perk allows you to sample up to three coffee so you can rate them and decide what you like before signing up. From there, they give you suggestions based on your taste profile.

One of the cool things about Crema is that you get to choose the selection of coffee sent to you, and you can even create a playlist of coffee that you can always adjust.

Atlas vs Crema Coffee: How Are They Similar?

There are many great benefits to choosing either Atlas Coffee Club or Crema Coffee as your coffee source. The two subscription services have a very big coffee variety, and they really want to educate people about the coffee they’re drinking.

Atlas Coffee Club Review

With Atlas, you can learn more about your beans through the postcards and country info that they give you in each shipment. With Crema, the more you rate coffees, the more you learn about them, and they also have good descriptions of each blend.

Another similarity with both coffee subscription boxes is that you can choose how frequent your deliveries are!

How Are They Different?

While Atlas Coffee Club gives you a choice with your delivery, they lack the ability to customize what coffee you get in your subscription. After the initial series of questions, which doesn’t allow for much customization, they choose which beans are sent to you based on those preferences.

Atlas Coffee Club

However, Crema Coffee lets you decide which coffee is delivered to you through a filtered search and the coffee playlist option. After you “try it free,” they even give you suggestions, on which you can base your taste profile.

In summary, you have less control over what you get with Atlas, but less guidance with Crema. Yet, you should also take a look at the differences in their subscription costs.

Atlas Coffee Club Pricing

Atlas Coffee Club gives you a choice of a 6-ounce bag of beans starting at $10, a 12-ounce bag starting at $16, or two 12-ounce bags starting at $32. While you can change the delivery frequency from every two weeks to every four weeks, the coffee only changes monthly.

Crema Coffee Pricing

Crema Coffee’s subscription service really depends on which coffee and roasters you choose, but you can also filter your search based on price. Because of this, costs average around $15-$20.

The bags of coffee only come in a 12-ounce bag or a 5-pound bag, but you still have the ability to change how often it’s delivered to you.

Which Coffee Subscription Box Is Right For You?

We know, that both of these coffee subscriptions are great choices for trying out new, amazing coffee! How do you pick just one? Well, if you still can’t decide after reading our review, we’ve also narrowed it down into one table so you can compare and contrast.

 Atlas Coffee ClubCrema Coffee
Single-origin or BlendSingle-originBlends and Single-origin
Sample SystemNo, just a short quiz"Try it free" sample option
CustomizationThey choose which coffee is sent to you based on preferencesYou choose which coffee is sent to you based on preferences and suggestions
RoastingFreshly roastedFreshly roasted from a wide range of roasters
Pricing$10-$32$15-$20

We hope this article helped you to pick a new coffee subscription box! We love how both Atlas Coffee Club and Crema Coffee work to educate coffee lovers on their coffee, origins, and flavor notes. Don’t be afraid to try something new, you never know what cup of coffee you’ll end up loving!

Happy Caffeinating!

Share the goods

Recommended Reads

  • Coffee Facts

    Why is Coffee So Expensive?

    You may have wondered, why is coffee so expensive? Let’s take a look at all the reasons why coffee might be so pricey!

  • Buying Guides

    Peaberry Coffee: Magical or Mythical?

    Fanatics claim that it's basically the the key to a coffee induced transcendence. Nay-sayers claim it is just a marketing ploy for companies to get more money. Read on to find the truth behind the Peaberry Coffee debate.

  • Coffee Facts

    Dutch Bros vs. Starbucks

    Dutch Bros and Starbucks offer all the features of high-quality coffee and signature drinks but is there an overall winner between the two?

  • Coffee Facts

    Vanuatu Coffee: Volcanic Roasting And Growing Coffee

    Located on islands on the South Pacific Ocean, the Vanuatu coffee grows close to volcanos that greatly benefits its taste. Check out our full guide.

  • Coffee Facts

    Dutch Coffee: A Cold Brew Mystery with History

    Maybe you have seen the term Dutch Coffee linked to odd contraptions at your local coffee shop. Or perhaps you've seen them mentioned when we talk about how coffee arrived in other regions. Read on to discover the Netherland's influence on global coffee culture and the answer to what exactly is "Dutch Coffee." 

  • Buying Guides

    The 11 Best Sumatra Coffees: A Buyers Guide

    If you've been roaming around through premium coffee lately, you've probably come across some mention of Sumatra Coffee. Whether you're here to learn more about how it tastes, how it's make, what brand to buy, or what exactly Kopi Luwak is, we have you covered in this guide. 

Brew like a Barista
from home

The Home Barista Coffee Course 14-lesson video course about brewing consistently amazing coffee at home. Stream or download the entire course to learn how to make coffee as good as your local barista for a fraction of the cost.

Like Free Coffee? Get your first bag free with an Atlas Coffee World Tour Click here to get the deal
Learn more