Buying Guides

Keurig K50 vs K55: Some Friendly Keurig Competition

Just so you know, if you click on a product on RoastyCoffee.com and decide to buy it, we may earn a small commission.

Are you looking to add a simple and convenient coffee companion to your kitchen? In your search, you may have come across these two startlingly similar models: the Keurig K50 vs K55. These are both relatively affordable entry-level models, but they can be pretty hard to tell apart.

Keurig K50 vs K55

We’re here to help make your decision a little bit easier. Read on for the full break down between the K-Classic (K55) and its predecessor, the K50. 

Single-Serve Coffee: What’s the Hype?

Above all, the hype around single-serve coffee is based on convenience. Over the past several years, Single-serve coffee machines have evolved into many different forms. Some simply downsize regular drip brewing mechanisms. Others have designed who lines of proprietary pods or capsules to accompany their machines.

Single-serve coffee makers, especially pod-based ones, won their popularity due to their efficiency and user-friendliness. Brands like Keurig and Nespresso work by piercing both ends of a coffee pod, heating water, and pouring the heated water through the pierced pod and a built-in filter. Then, it flows right into your cup. 

Fair warning, single-serve coffee isn’t going to get you the freshest or tastiest brew out there. But it will likely get you one of the fastest and easiest. So whether you continue on your hunt depends entirely on your lifestyle needs and personal preferences.

Should you get one?

If your main concerns are convenience and speed, single-serve brewing will likely suit you. These brewers will ger you a solidly OK cup of joe as you are running out of the door in the morning. So they’re perfect for people who just want something simple and easy. Plus the lower brewing temps mean less cool-down time.

However, if you have relatively high standards on flavor and reliability, single-serve (especially these Keurig 1.0 models we’re looking at in this article) might not be the way to go. If you want a bit more versatility and reliability with the same option to brew a single serving, you may want to invest in something like a Ninja coffee maker

About the Brand: Keurig

Keurig was born in the early 1990s and was initially marketed towards small offices for company break rooms. However, they eventually expanded into the home market, where their products have taken off. 

Over the past several years, Keurig has become a household name in single-serve coffee, especially in the American market. They offer a number of single-serve brewers for both at-home and in-office use. Plus, the sell plenty of accessories including carafes, filters, and coffee pods. 

Now, their machine range accommodates a number of budgets and styles from super basic models to bells-and-whistles galore. Overall, while these brewers might not satisfy your local café hipster, they get the job done for most average coffee drinkers. And the convenience factor is a pretty huge plus. 

A Keurig Competition

Keurig K50

The older Keurig K50 measures 9.8″ x 13″ x 13.3″ and weighs 7.6 lbs. It has the standard removable drip tray and a 48-ounce removable water reservoir. It is advertised as having a less than 60-second brew time (though it is known to take slightly longer than that).

Things we like:

  • Relatively versatile for such a small machine
  • Button controls are simple and user-friendly
  • The auto-off feature kicks in after 90 seconds

Things we don’t:

  • Brewing is noisy
  • Coffee has a noticeable plastic-y aftertaste
  • Some machines have disappointingly short lifespans

Keurig K55 or K-Classic

The K55 is slightly larger and heavier than the K50, coming in at 10.6 lbs and measuring 10.1″x13.2″x13.3″.  Like the K50, it has a removable drip tray and a 48-ounce removable water reservoir. This one also seems to keep the promise of a <1 minute brew time.

On Sale

Things we like:

  • Significantly more reliable than the K50
  • Brewing takes less than a minute
  • Addition of indicator lights helps keep up with maintenance 

Things we don’t:

  • No control over coffee strength (makes for weak brews)
  • The brewing process is noisier than the previous model

Features that Matter

Brewing

Both the K50 and K55 can brew 6, 8, and 10 oz cups. However, neither of them allows for any strength, temperature, or pressure customization, meaning they tend to put out relatively weak brews. Nonetheless, they can both handle coffee, tea, hot water, and some specialty drinks (like iced coffee). So they should cover your basic coffee needs. 

As far as the actual brews, the K55 seems to put out better quality cups than the K50. As mentioned above, there tends to be a plastic aftertaste with the K50 brews. Additionally, the K55 is compatible with the My K-Cup while the K50 is not. That means you’re potentially able to use fresher grounds with the K55, making for a better brew than you can get with the pre-packaged pods. 

Reliability 

The consistency and quality of a coffee brewing product tend to be the number one concern for people when buying a brewer. Overall, Keurig products aren’t designed to last you a lifetime. They are primarily composed of plastic parts, meaning they wear out relatively quickly. 

Unfortunately, this construction choice negatively affects one of these machines far more than the other. Users have consistently expressed dissatisfaction with the K50 on this front. Despite the very similar construction, the K55’s tend to far outlast their predecessors.

Controls and Design

Visually, the K50 and K55 are nearly identical. The K55 does come in more colors, adding rhubarb and white in addition to the classic black. Though the K55 is slightly larger and weightier than the K50, the difference is virtually unnoticeable. 

As far as control panels go, these machines are also twins. They both have 5 control buttons: 3 for sizes, one power button, and one to control auto-off. There are also 5 indicator lights: add water, descale, heating, auto-off, and descale. 

Cleaning and Maintenance

One notable improvement between the K50 and K55 is the addition of an auto-descaling feature. This significantly improves the ease with which you can perform maintenance on the machine. This likely also contributes to the improved reliability of the newer model.

The Verdict

Overall, the K-Classic is the better of these two choices. At this point, the K50 has become a little too dated. While at one point it was definitely at the forefront of single-serve brewing, its successor has since overtaken it. While the machine is not useless by any means, it simply is no longer reliable or versatile enough to warrant the investment.

Also, as Keurig has begun phasing out the machine, it is becoming increasingly harder to find in stores or online. 

The K-Classic or K55, on the other hand, remains one of Keurig’s best sellers with little to no signs of being retired any time soon, even with the introduction of the Keurig 2.0 line. Plus, it is still quite affordable. So if you are looking for a basic, convenient single-serve pod brewer, we recommend the K55. 

On Sale
Share the goods

Recommended Reads

  • Buying Guides

    The Ninja Specialty Coffee Maker: All You Need In a Coffee Machine

    Are you a fan of brewing coffee in the comfort of your own kitchen? Searching for a machine that's affordable, dependable, versatile, AND makes good coffee? The Ninja Specialty Coffee Maker might be just what you've been looking for.

  • Coffee Facts

    Illy vs Nespresso: Choosing Your Capsule Companion

    Today, we're taking a look at two brands that dominate in the global market, but you may not have seen too much of in the States: Illy vs Nespresso. Read on for in-depth comparisons of pods and machines so you can find the pod-ner that works for you.

  • Buying Guides

    Capresso Burr Grinder: To Infinity and…Coffee?

    The entry-level electric coffee grinder market is fairly competitive, so it can be difficult to decide which machine is best for you. Here, we'll be reviewing the Capresso Burr Grinder lineup, including the Infinity, Infinity Plus, and even the base-level Coffee Burr Grinder.

  • Coffee Facts

    Clever Coffee Dripper: The Brew Review

    What if we told you that there's a new tool on the block that people are saying might out shine your French Press, Pour over, AND drip brewer? Well, buckle up because this review might. just blow your mind. Today, we're looking at the Clever Coffee Dripper and investigating what actually makes. it so clever.

  • Buying Guides

    OXO Barista Brain Review- How We’re in Love with You

    The Oxo Barista Brain is a coffee maker like no other, with the ability to brew anywhere from one to nine cups at a time. Check out our full review.

  • Buying Guides

    Breville Creatista Plus Review: Match Made in Heaven?

    Like the idea of a Nespresso capsule machine but still want a little something extra to spice up the experience? This Breville+Nespresso collaboration machine might be perfect for you. Check out the full story in this Breville Creatista Plus review.

Brew like a Barista
from home

The Home Barista Coffee Course 14-lesson video course about brewing consistently amazing coffee at home. Stream or download the entire course to learn how to make coffee as good as your local barista for a fraction of the cost.

Learn more