Buying Guides

Mistobox vs. Blue Bottle Coffee Subscription Review

While Mistobox Coffee and Blue Bottle Coffee try their hardest to make sure you’re receiving freshly roasted coffee, Mistobox has a wide variety of beans, and Blue Bottle has a very select list of bean options.


Just so you know, if you click on a product on RoastyCoffee.com and decide to buy it, we may earn a small commission.

Many coffee subscription services work hard to set themselves apart from others. What you pick really depends on what you prefer to prioritize in your subscription.

We found two, Mistobox Coffee and Blue Bottle Coffee, that have incentives to drive customers to their service. In this article, we’ll tell you exactly how what they provide and what sets them apart.

mistobox vs blue bottle

What is Mistobox Coffee?

Mistobox Review
MISTOBOX COFFEE SUBSCRIPTION
Our rating:
  • Personalized coffee selections
  • Freshly-roasted whole bean and pre-ground options
  • Each 12 oz. bag makes ~24 cups of coffee
  • Delivered on your schedule straight to your door
Check Price

Mistobox Coffee is a subscription box that prides itself on a wide variety of coffee beans from many different countries and a huge range of roasting options. With over 500 blend options to choose from and access to 50 of the most talented roasters, Mistobox makes sure to offer their customers something new every time.

Mistobox Coffee on table

Based on your preferences, Mistobox will match you with coffee, and you can then pick which beans you want to be sent to you and even create a “Brew Queue.”

As the coffee is roasted to order, they also guarantee freshness, even with a customizable delivery schedule.

What is Blue Bottle Coffee?

Blue Bottle Coffee Subscription
BLUE BOTTLE SUBSCRIPTION
Our rating:

We source great coffees, roast them to perfection, and get them to you fresh. Try your first coffee bag on us!

Like Free Coffee? Get your first bag free with an Atlas Coffee World Tour Click here to get the deal
Check Price

Blue Bottle Coffee’s subscription service makes sure to provide its customers with the freshest coffee and blends that are professionally crafted.

Bags of coffee shipped out no more than 24 hours after they are roasted, and Blue Bottle has many different subscription options.

Blue Bottle Coffee Subscription

Blue Bottle has a special option if you want a standard subscription in either a blend, single-origin, or espresso format, but you don’t have the tools to make your coffee.

The Welcome Kit subscription includes three months of coffee, a coffee dripper, coffee filters, and even a tote bag to get you properly started with your coffee subscription.

Mistobox vs Blue Bottle: How Are They Similar?

It’s easy to see that Mistobox Coffee and Blue Bottle Coffee are similar in providing subscribers with quality, freshly roasted coffee.

They also give you a short quiz at the start of your subscription to understand your coffee preferences and flavor profile. Moreover, they both allow you to change the frequency of your coffee deliveries.

How Are They Different?

However, Mistobox Coffee and Blue Bottle Coffee differ in many ways. The main contrast is that Mistobox emphasizes its wide range of selection in both coffee beans and roasters. But Blue Bottle takes note of its smaller selection and focuses on ensuring the coffee they provide is of the highest quality and freshness.

Another important difference is how Mistobox allows you to choose exactly which coffee is getting sent to you and the order it’s delivered in. Yet, Blue Bottle selects blends for you based on your preferences and the order you receive them due to their own coffee sourcing schedule.

MistoBox Coffee Subscription

Mistobox also offers subscribers the choice of either whole-bean or ground coffee, but Blue Bottle solely sells whole-bean coffee.

The size option for Mistobox is limited to a 12-ounce bag, but Blue Bottle offers sizes in 6-ounce or 12-ounce bags of beans, with the option to order up to 24 ounces or 36 ounces of coffee beans.

Mistobox Coffee Pricing

When looking at the cost comparisons, Mistobox Coffee’s prices are based on their subscription tiers. If you were to get the Basic tier, which simply provides you with good coffee, it would start at $10.95 before shipping.

Mistobox Coffee Pouring

The Deluxe tier, designed for coffee experts, starts at $12.71 before shipping, and the Exclusive tier, which gives you access to very limited roasts, starts at $15.26 before shipping fees.

The delivery frequency for Mistobox varies from every week to every month, and you can always cancel or pause your subscription.

Blue Bottle Coffee Pricing

With Blue Bottle Coffee, prices are based on what type of subscription you get. While you can get a free trial, where you can choose between blend, single-origin, or espresso, it only lasts ten days.

After that, you can start a standard Blue Bottle coffee subscription in either the blend assortment, which starts at $13, the single-origin coffee assortment, which starts at $15, or the espresso assortment, which starts at $13.

The prices vary depending on what size bag you choose, but shipping is included no matter what. The frequency of shipments for Blue Bottle is also set from every week to every four weeks.

If you choose to get the Welcome Kit subscription, which comes with three months worth of coffee, a coffee dripper, a 90-pack of coffee filters, and a tote bag, you would be getting a $199 value set at the price of $155.

Get Your Coffee How You Want It

If you’re still stuck between choosing one of these awesome coffee subscription boxes, don’t worry. We made a table of everything we’ve talked about so that it’s easier to decide!

 Mistobox CoffeeBlue Bottle Coffee
Blend or Single-OriginBlend and Single-OriginBlend and Single-Origin
CustomizationYou can pick which coffee is delivered to you and whenThey pick what coffee is delivered to you and when
RoastingFreshly roasted and shipped within a few daysFreshly roasted and shipped in no more than 24 hours
Free SamplesNoYes
Bag Size12-ounce bag6- or 12-ounce bag, or in 24 or 36-ounce amounts
Pricing$11-$16 plus shippingStarts at $13-$15, shipping included. Welcome Kit: $155

Simply put, Mistobox Coffee and Blue Bottle Coffee are subscription services that offer quality, fresh coffee and strive to provide their customers with only the best delicious coffee.

We love both of these coffee subscriptions! It really just depends on what you find to be more important when it comes to your subscription; a large selection of coffees or guaranteed quality and freshness.

Happy Caffeinating!

Share the goods

Recommended Reads

Brew like a Barista
from home

The Home Barista Coffee Course 14-lesson video course about brewing consistently amazing coffee at home. Stream or download the entire course to learn how to make coffee as good as your local barista for a fraction of the cost.

Like Free Coffee? Get your first bag free with an Atlas Coffee World Tour Click here to get the deal
Learn more