Coffee Facts

How To Tell If Coffee Is Rancid And What To Do If It Is


Just so you know, if you click on a product on RoastyCoffee.com and decide to buy it, we may earn a small commission.

A while back, there was an awesome deal for a batch of coffee beans at one of those bulk stores, so I decided to stock up — and I mean stock up. It was around bag three when the flavor started to fall flat, and I realized my mistake. Coffee, like all crops, will eventually fall victim to time. The worst part? I had two more (giant) bags to go!

Maybe you’re a bulk shopper who plans to stock up on your favorite type of coffee, or perhaps you’ve stumbled across an old bag of beans hidden in the back of a cupboard. Either way, learning the signs of expired joe and why it matters is essential if you’re passionate about drinking the freshest coffee possible. 

Time can be a thief, so let’s learn how to protect what matters most! 

HOW LONG BEFORE COFFEE GOES BAD?

Coffee does go bad. But not in the sense of growing mold or poisoning you. Bad coffee just tastes and smells “off.” How long your batch of beans will last depends on the type of coffee it is. If you store the coffee properly, the general rule of thumb is:

Need Gift Ideas For A Coffee Lover We’ve got 29 unique gift ideas for 2022 for all budgets Click here to check them out
  • Whole beans: six to nine months 
  • Ground coffee: three to five months
  • Instant coffee: two to 20 years

There are variables to the expiry guidelines, of course. Large factory whole bean roasters, like Lavazza, undertake nitrogen flushes, which prolong the expiration date. If you freeze coffee (and if you do…please stop!), you’ll push the expiration date further. And once opened and exposed to oxygen, you’ll need to store it correctly. Learn more about coffee expiration here

THE SIGNS OF RANCID COFFEE 

The Signs Of Rancid Coffee Graphic

You can’t really see bad coffee; maybe it will lose a little color, but the change is pretty subtle and hard to judge. So, the best method is to dive right in there with your nose…and mouth.

Don’t worry — you won’t be gagging on sour garbage smells or vomiting from the taste. It just won’t be as good as it should be. These are a few questions you may be asking as you learn how to identify coffee spoilage.

What does rancid coffee smell like? 

Rancid coffee’s smell can best be described as dusty, mildewy, or flat.

Fresh coffee smells of…well, fresh coffee. With new beans, you’ll catch a whiff of the coffee flavors, like the deliciously nutty and caramel notes you love so much. The scent of old and stale coffee might be more akin to an ashtray or vacuum; that pleasant aroma will just be missing. This is true for all bean types — ground, whole, and instant coffee. 

What does rancid coffee taste like? 

Bad coffee’s taste is somewhere on the spectrum of dull to sour. 

Time robs stellar coffees of all their diverse and interesting flavors, leaving something that tastes pretty empty. After enough time, more sour, bitter notes will develop. I’ve even had a friend tell me an old bag was as sharp as a lemon!

The best way to detect an off taste is to brew a cup and leave it to cool for an hour. Take a sip, and if you pick up on more sour and bitter tastes than usual, the contents of your coffee bag might be bad.

But wait! Before chucking your beans based on taste alone, you should know that gross flavors can also be attributed to bad brewing! Be sure you didn’t under-extract or make any of these common brewing mistakes.

Other ways to detect rancid coffee 

Before tasting your brew, you might get a clue if your coffee is bad by checking the crema. Fresh beans will always produce a thin layer of crema on top. If you have a cup of thin black coffee with no layer of microbubbles, it’s a sign of aged beans. 

For uber-fresh whole beans, you can check carbon dioxide levels. Chuck a handful of beans in a Ziplock bag with all the air removed. Leave it overnight at room temperature. If your bag has puffed up in the morning, your beans are fresh, probably no more than 10 days old. If there is still no air, you’ve got some older beans on your hands.

This is an effective test, as beans emit CO2 until they eventually oxidize. Beans more than 10 days old are certainly not considered rancid, and they can still produce great coffee. But coffee snobs out there would consider the joe past its prime.

CAN YOU GET FOOD POISONING FROM OLD COFFEE? 

The chances of bacteria forming on your beans are minimal, leaving poisoning low risk. Some people will have no problem going past the shelf life. In which case, I’d suggest using extra coffee, adding sweeteners or flavors, or enjoying your coffee with milk to gain back some of the lost taste. 

Disclaimer: consuming spoiled food and beverages presents certain health risks. Practice safe consumption, kids!

HOW TO MAKE COFFEE LAST LONGER 

Treat your coffee right, and you’ll have a beautiful long relationship. Top tips: 

  • Invest in one of the many airtight containers for coffee storage on the market to lock oxygen out.
  • Make sure your coffee container is opaque to keep the coffee safe from light. 
  • Keep your coffee in a cool, dark space to keep heat and moisture out.
  • Don’t freeze your coffee. Yes, people do it, but it can destroy the beans’ flavor. Learn more about that here.

WHAT TO DO WITH EXPIRED COFFEE 

Before chucking that coffee you’ve deemed spoiled, run through the smell and taste tests. If it was sealed and stored correctly, it may still be good. But if it’s actually rancid, avoid waste by recycling your beans. How do you do that? We’re glad you asked!

  1. Baking: There are so many recipes that call for coffee…tiramisu, brownies, meat rubs, syrups, cakes, you name it! Just make sure the coffee isn’t too far gone, as it can add sour notes to your food. 
  2. Gardening: Use ground coffee to fertilize your garden. Not only does it add essential nutrients to the soil for plant growth, but it can also attract worms!
  3. Repulsion: Insects like mosquitos and pests (like slugs) hate coffee because it has compounds that are toxic to them. Sprinkle the joe around your outdoor seating areas and plants to keep bugs away.
  4. Exfoliation: Mix grounds into coconut oil to create a body scrub that removes dirt and dead skin, leaving you feeling unbelievably soft. 

WHY FRESH MATTERS 

End of that day, fresh coffee is best. Period. But if you can’t get sick from expired coffee, why does it matter? Well, I suppose it doesn’t…unless you want to drink a flavorful morning cup with a pleasing aroma and smooth mouthfeel.

Serious coffee drinkers will tell you a coffee’s shelf life is different from its taste life. Coffee’s peak flavor is found between one to three weeks after the roast date. Espresso’s sweet spot occurs between two and four weeks after roasting. With each passing day, the beans lose their aroma and potential for crema. 

At the end of the day, though, it’s your level of coffee elitism and taste preferences that will ultimately guide you to decide if your beloved beans are bad. 

I believe life is too short to drink bad coffee…which is why I’ve got a gallon of body scrub and a blooming garden, thanks to my poor bulk buy decision.

Happy caffeinating!

Like Free Coffee? Get your first bag free with an Atlas Coffee World Tour Click here to get the deal
Share the goods

Recommended Reads

  • Coffee Facts

    Coffee Tamer and The Truth Behind Coffee’s Acidity

    Coffee acidity can cause problems for people with acid reflux, heartburn or interstitial cystitis. Check out our tips on coffee tamers to enjoy coffee with no pain.

  • Coffee Facts

    What Is Shade-Grown Coffee?

    Sun or shade? These two words mean a world of difference in the coffee-growing industry. If you love good coffee and care about environmental preservation, you need to know about the little known secret of shade-grown coffee. And we've got all you need to know right here.

  • Coffee Facts

    How to Choose the Best Water for Coffee

    Choosing the best water for your coffee can actually be a very important part of how the taste turns out. Check out our tips to choose the right type of water.

  • Coffee Facts

    How and Why to Switch to Black Coffee

    Learn to ditch that cream and sugar once and for all by learning how to drink black coffee and enjoying all the natural flavors that it provides.

  • How to Brew

    How to Measure Coffee: Coffee to Water Ratio Calculator

    Ever been confused on what coffee to water ratio you should use per cup of coffee? Our simple coffee to water calculator & chart makes brewing perfect coffee easy. Stop eyeballing it and let us do the coffee math for you.

  • Coffee Facts

    Egg Coffee: Egg-cellent Idea or Totally Scrambled?

    Egg coffee might sound like a prank, but we can assure you that this Vietnamese egg coffee is no joke. Read on; you might actually find yourself a new favorite treat!

Brew like a Barista
from home

The Home Barista Coffee Course 14-lesson video course about brewing consistently amazing coffee at home. Stream or download the entire course to learn how to make coffee as good as your local barista for a fraction of the cost.

Learn more