Isn’t cold brew the same as iced coffee? Nope! Though both can be loved equally, they aren’t equal in ingredients or makeup at all. We here at Roasty loved both a good ‘ole cup of iced coffee and cold brew, but we also know that there are significant differences between these two spunky coffee drinks.
At A Glance: Our Top 6 Picks for Cold Brew Coffee Makers
Quick Summary: The Best Cold Brew Coffee Maker
|Filtron Cold Coffee Concentrate Brewer||Check on Amazon →|
|Toddy Cold Brew System||Check on Amazon →|
|Yama Glass 6-8 Cup Cold Drip Maker||Check on Amazon →|
|Coffee Gator Cold Brewer||Check on Amazon →|
|OXO Good Grips Cold Brew Coffee Maker||Check on Amazon →|
|DCB-10 Automatic Cold Brew Coffee Maker||Check on Amazon →|
|Stone Street Coffee Cold Brew Whole Bean Coffee||Check on Amazon →|
What Makes It Cold Brew?
Cold brew refers to a coffee brewing method that involves steeping coarse grounds in cold water or room temperature water. Many coffee lovers prefer cold brew because of the robust flavoring, and some coffee fanatics even argue that the cold brewing method is the best way to highlight the innermost flavor in the beans. During the cold brew process, the grounds never introduced to hot water, and the process usually takes about 12 to 24 hours; however, come brewers allow you to make it in less.
So…Not Iced Coffee?
Unlike cold brew coffee, iced coffee is brewed hot then served over ice. This difference creates a distinct flavor profile that many find preferable to regular iced or hot coffee.
In addition, while cold coffee can be served over ice, it is not the same as iced coffee, which involves pouring hot coffee over ice. And let’s be honest, hot brewed coffee that’s been chilled to be poured over ice goes stale/sour faster and easier due to the change in temperature.
Not only do many coffee lovers prefer cold brew coffee over iced coffee because of the flavor profiles, but many also prefer cold brew coffee because it stays fresher longer. With one batch of cold brew, you can actually store it in your fridge and sip on it for about a week! As far as other notable features of cold brew, some other popular reasons why many enjoy it are for the low acidity, high caffeine content, as well as extraordinary health benefits.
The Best Cold Brew Coffee Makers
There’s a cold brew coffee maker out there that’s made for everyone. Unfortunately, searching for the perfect one can be somewhat overwhelming. That’s why we’ve scoured around high and low, and here are our choices of some of the best cold brew makers on the market today.
Filtron Cold Coffee Concentrate Brewer
The Filtron gets its bragging rights from its ease-of-use and consistency. This model features measurement lines to help even total cold brew beginners. Plus, once you figure out your brewing sweet spot, they’ll help you get exactly what you want, every time.
Additionally, you can store up to 1.5 liters of cold brew for about 2 weeks in this brewer. It’s also suitable for both hot and cold beverages. So even if you get tired of cold brew (though that’s unlikely), you can always mix things up.
Once ordered, the product package includes a coffee bowl, water bowl, filter pad, rubber stopper, grounds guard, measuring cup, decanter, and 2 sample paper filters. Though you don’t have to use paper filters with this product, if you want to emphasize the crisp, clean taste of the cold brew, we recommend getting some large commercial-sized filters to pair with this brewer.
For the most part, coffee lovers are usually pretty satisfied with this Filtron. However, there have been some complaints of the handle being defective and the plastic housing is cracked. So, make sure to thoroughly inspect yours when it arrives.
Toddy Cold Brew System
Most users who don’t mesh well with the Filtron opt for this Toddy model instead. Similar in functionality though not in design, this model includes a brewing container with handle, a glass decanter with lid, 2 reusable filters, 1 rubber stopper, a set of instructions, and a recipe guide. It’s also a machine that’s easy to use and offers some of the best
Cold brew coffee generally has a lower acid content; however, Toddy boasts an impressive 67% less acidic coffee concentrate using your regular, go-to ground coffee/coffee beans. You can make about 1.5 liters at a time, and it’ll last in your fridge for 2 weeks. Talk about low maintenance!
When using this product, as with most cold brew methods, make sure you have a coarse grind to prevent any grittiness. Also, make sure to maintain and replace your Toddy filter regularly.
Takeya Cold Brew Maker
Looking for something simple to begin brewing with? The Takeya is an easy-to-use, easy-to-clean cold brew maker that can produce some of the most robust, rich cold brew you can acquire. Made out of BPA-free material, the Takeya has an airtight lid and a non-slip silicone handle that’s strong and durable and will last you a long time if taken care of properly.
I can produce about 4 -5 servings of smooth cold brew coffee, and it uses a fine mesh filter to ensure that no coffee grounds slip into the finished brew. It comes in two different sizes, 1 quart or 2 quarts, yet it’s compact enough to fit in any sized refrigerator.
In addition, the Takeya is super lightweight, making it easy to move and handle. Furthermore, since it’s simple in construction, the Takeya is also more portable than some other cold brewing systems.
Yama Glass 6-8 Cup Cold Drip Maker
If you’ve got a bigger budget or are looking to add a little intrigue to your countertop, this Kyoto-style Yama model is for you. One of the most highly recognized cold drip coffee makers on the market, the Yama is an ideal choice for those looking to bring out the complex, subtle notes of single-origin or otherwise special beans.
With the steep price tag comes some pretty sweet upgrades to your regular cold brewer. The design allows you to get your beverage of choice in about 3 to 4 hours, rather than the 16 to 24 hours that most other models need.
The Yama integrates quality craftsmanship down to the materials used for the system. It features non-porous borosilicate glass, meaning it’ll last you longer and you won’t have to worry about mold (which is an issue with plastic options). Additionally, the mid-century style tower is made of real wood and compliments nearly any aesthetic. Even the permanent filter is premium quality ceramic.
Other than the prohibitive price, the only drawback is the size. This coffee maker has a smaller capacity than some of the cheaper options on the list at about a liter ( 32 oz).
Coffee Gator Cold Brewer
In contrast to the YAMA, the Coffee Gator Cold Brew Coffee Maker is ultra-simple to use and is one of the most affordable cold brew options on the market. But don’t let the price fool you; this brewer packs a serious punch.
This product includes a metal scoop, collapsible funnel, detachable grounds filter, making it both easy to use and to clean. The plastic components are BPA free and the glass is durable borosilicate.
The Gator’s carafe can hold a respectable 1.4 liters (approximately), and with proper care, it should be durable enough to last you a while. Just make sure not to rinse it with hot water immediately after taking it out of the fridge.
Even if you do run into an issue with this product, Coffee Gator’s customer service is known for its responsiveness. So you should be able to get it sorted out in a jiffy.
OXO Good Grips Cold Brew Coffee Maker
If the idea of pot-style brewing doesn’t really do it for you, the bucket-style OXO coffee maker might suit you nicely. The OXO Good Grips are designed for more flexibility and experimentation for the more adventurous at-home baristas out there.
While this design differs from many of the other models we’ve shown you, it’s just as user-friendly. It features a borosilicate glass carafe with clearly marked measurements, as well as a stopper to preserve freshness, an ultra-fine reusable stainless steel mesh filter and, 10 paper filters.
All of the components are lend themselves to easy disassembly, making for a simple clean-up. The main thing you’ll have to keep an eye out for on this model is leakage due to a faulty or worn-out filter.
DCB-10 Automatic Cold Brew Coffee Maker
Don’t have the patience to wait 12-24 hours for cold brew? Then this automatic Cuisinart might be the brewer for you. The DCB-10 can brew 7 cups of coffee in just 25-45 minutes.
While the taste of the coffee you get from this machine isn’t quite as well developed as that of a more traditional method, saving a solid 11+ hours of time makes it worth it. The amount of time this machine takes depends on the strength of brew you select. Mild takes 25 minutes, medium 35, and bold 45.
This machine brews your coffee by agitating the water and grounds until enough flavor has been extracted for your liking. Then, an indicator light comes on, you pull a lever, and Voila! Coffee is served.
The main drawback of this machine is that there’s a chance of buildup in the removable tank. However, all removable parts are dishwasher safe, and the machine has a limited 3-year warranty. So, this shouldn’t be a major issue.
Why Choose Cold Brew?
There are many reasons why people choose cold brew coffee over other forms of coffee. From flavor, to brewing preferences, to health benefits, here are some of the most prominent reasons that cold brew is held in such high regard amongst the coffee community.
One of the biggest differences between your regular cup of joe and cold brew is the acidity. Usually, when coffee is brewed with hot water, there are certain oils that are released from the coffee grounds when they’re heated.
However, for cold brewing, the coffee never comes into contact with heat, so the extraction of these acidic oils is minimized. The presence of acidic oils are what creates a bitter taste in some brewed coffees, and also results in higher acidity, making it a little bit more difficult for those who have sensitive stomachs.
As a result, you’ll get a cup that is much lighter and smoother. The low acidity also means people who suffer from acid reflux or who have sensitive stomachs may be able to enjoy this kind of coffee without a hitch.
Due to the extended steeping required for cold brew, the concentrate produces has a much higher coffee to water ratio than regular brews. However, despite the increased concentration, cold brew generally doesn’t have an overwhelmingly strong flavor. This is also a result of a lack of heat and subsequent oil release. Thus, you should end up with a palatable beverage that packs a serious caffeine punch.
However, cold brew is often diluted with the usual suspects (milk, creamer, water, etc). This results in a less concentrated drink. Plus, there are a couple of other factors that affect the strength of your coffee, including the coffee beans and steep time.
There are many benefits of cold brew to those who are regularly physically active. Since cold brew has a plentiful amount of caffeine, in addition, the increased caffeine also means cold brew can help you burn fat post-workout, as it increases your post-energy expenditure or after-burn effect.
In addition to the extra energy boost, cold brew coffee also possesses a high amount of antioxidants and free-radical fighting chemicals. If you want the full low-down on the benefits of cold brew, you can check out our other article on it here.
Things to Consider Before Buying
Before putting your money where your mouth is, there are some important things you need to consider before officially choosing your ideal cold brew coffee maker. Here are some of the most important characteristics to take into account:
With cold brew, you are going to want a fresh supply of ground coffee. However, you’ll need to make sure that your coffee is of coarse grind size so that the flavors within the coffee can be extracted properly.
When we say fresh we mean, you-ground-it-yourself level freshness. This is because cold brew coffee tends to have a subtler, weaker flavor than regular coffee. So, having a fresh grind will help ensure that you get the most flavor possible from your beans of choice.
Furthermore, the grind should be coarse to help with extraction. Because most of the brewing happens over a long steeping process, you will get better results if the water can reach more grounds. This is easier with a coarser grind.
As always, size matters more than you think. Not only do you need to make sure that the footprint of your brewer can fit on your countertop, but you also have to check it’s height. If the perfect brewer is too tall to fit on the shelf of your refrigerator, it won’t do you much good.
The two main styles of cold brewing systems are called immersion and slow drips. Most of the models we’ve mentioned ere fall into the immersion-style, which includes two subcategories: pot and bucket. These involve submerging coarse-ground coffee in water for roughly 16 hours. Then, you simply filter and drink.
Pot-style brewers tend to be a little slower and require you to pour the finished mixture through a filter. This process results in a more tea-like taste and feel. On the other hand, bucket-style mechanisms generally involve a lever or switch you interact with to allow the brew to drain through a filter and into a carafe below. The result tends to be slightly richer and more robust.
Generally speaking, immersion-style brewers tend to leave more sediment in your drink than drip brewers. However, using a paper filter or filtering multiple times can remedy this issue. It also tends to help highlight more rich, chocolatey notes.
In contrast, a slow cold drip coffee maker will tend to produce a lighter mouthfeel and flavor. These models help bring out citrus and other sweeter flavors.
Ease of Use
If this is your first rodeo, it might be better to invest in one of the more user-friendly models, such as the Gator, Filtron, or Toddy brewer. Look for easy assembly/disassembly, maintenance requirements, and clear volume markings for measurements.
However, if you have a good bit of experience with manual brewing methods or even specifically cold brew systems, other options might be within your reach.
Likewise, you should also make sure that your cold brew coffee maker is easy to hold, clean, and more. The most important characteristics that will influence how easy it is to use your cold brewer are the materials it’s made of and the accessories built into it.
For example, if your cold brew coffee maker has a glass carafe, it may look sleek in design, but has a higher risk of cracking and shattering. On the other hand, if your coffee maker has parts that are made with stainless steel, it will help protect it from any accidental breakage.
Another important cosmetic characteristic that you may want to look for in a coffee maker is the presence of good grips to not only make it easy to use but also easy to hold.
What About The French Press?
Many coffee fanatics argue that there is one brewing method that makes some of the best cold brew with the least amount of hassle. Instead of purchasing a dedicated cold brew device, many coffee addicts simply opt to make their cold brew in a French press.
You can get the full breakdown of that process here, but we’ve included some of the basics below. If you don’t already have a French press, we highly recommend trying one out. Other than that, you’ll need your favorite beans, a grinder (unless you MUST use pre-ground), water, and a spoon.
You’ll simply add cold water into your fresh, coarse grounds with a ratio of about 1 part coffee to 7 parts water. Slowly and thoroughly stir the mixture. Then, put the press in your refrigerator and let it steep for 12+ hours.
Finally, do a full 30-second plunge, as usual, with the French press. If you’re having trouble with the grittiness of french press coffee, you can pour the coffee through a paper filter to get a little closer to the classic cold brew mouthfeel.
The Conclusion On Cold Brew
So if you are on the market for a brewing method that can give you a crisp, low-acid, energizing cup of coffee, a cold brew coffee maker might be for you.
So remember, when you’re on the search for the best cold brew coffee maker, any of the above models should make you a great cup of joe. However, make sure you consider how much space you have available, what style of brewer suits your tastes, and how much experience with alternative brewing you have.
With a product from this list, your favorite coffee, a little water, and some patience, you’ll be able to enjoy the light delight of cold brew coffee.