Buying Guides

Organic Coffee: A Guide to Buying Better Beans

Just so you know, if you click on a product on and decide to buy it, we may earn a small commission.

First off, conventional coffee is known to be among one of the most chemically treated foods in the world. And while that might not affect you as a consumer thanks to coffee’s protective fruit and the roasting process, it certainly does have an impact on farmers and the environment.

Don’t Feel Like Reading? If you want a tasty, freshly roasted organic coffee you can buy online, try something from LifeBoost and thank me later.  Click here to check it out and save 40%.

Farmers may be exposed to high level of chemicals while treating or handling crops if they are not provided with proper equipment to protect themselves. Additionally, runoff may affect surround communities as well. Thus, there has been a recent push to find ways to ensure that coffee is being produced in a way that people feel they can support.

At A Glance: Our Top 5 Picks for Organic Coffee

One such push has come in the form of the rapidly growing organic coffee market. And that’s what we’re talking about today. We have everything from what “organic” really means to what brands with the label we actually think are worth buying.

organic coffee

Quick Summary: The Best Organic Coffee

rc-table__imageLifeBoost Coffee
  • 100% Organic Coffee
  • High Quality
  • Clean, Healthy, Non-GMO, Pesticide-Free
Check On Lifeboost→
  • Comforting And Rich
  • Apricot, Cacao Nib, Caramel
  • Classic Drip Blend
Check Price →
  • With A Chocolaty Body And Caramel Sweetness
  • Roasty And Smoky
  • Big-Bodied And Sweet
Check Price →
DEATH WISH COFFEE Whole Bean Coffee [16 oz.] The World's Strongest, USDA Certified Organic, Fair Trade, Arabica and Robusta Beans (1-Pack)Death Wish Coffee
  • USDA Organic
  • Formulated For A Smooth, Never-Bitter Taste
  • Has Notes Of Cherry And Chocolate
Check on Amazon →
Kicking Horse Coffee Smart Ass - WHOLE BEAN, 10 oz, Pack of 2Kicking Horse Coffee Smart Ass
  • USDA Organic
  • Roasted In Canada
  • Certified By Ecocert Canada (COR)
Check on Amazon →
Kicking Horse Coffee, Three Sisters, Medium Roast, Whole Bean, 10 Oz - Certified Organic, Fairtrade, Kosher CoffeeKicking Horse Coffee, Three Sisters
  • Medium Roast
  • Whole Beans
  • Organic
Check on Amazon →
Camano Island Coffee Roasters - Organic Sumatra Dark Roast Coffee - Fresh Premium USDA Certified Organic, Shade Grown, Fair Trade, and EthicalCamano Island Coffee Organic Sumatra
  • Fresh Roasted Coffee
  • USDA Certified Organic
  • 30 Day Money Back Guarantee
Check on Amazon →
Tiny Footprint Coffee - Organic Cold Brew Cold Press Elixir | Whole Bean Coffee | USDA Organic | Carbon Negative | 16 OunceTiny Footprint Organic Cold Brew Coffee
  • 100% Organic Shade-Grown Arabica Coffee
  • Carbon Negative And Earth Positive
  • A Blend Crafted Perfectly For Cold Brew
Check on Amazon →
Cameron's Coffee Roasted Whole Bean Coffee, Organic French Roast, 28 OunceCameron's Coffee Organic French Roast
  • Uniquely Handicrafted Coffee
  • Rich And Flavorful
  • Organic Blends
Check on Amazon →
Organic One Love, Ethiopian YirgaCheffe Ground Coffee, 8 OunceMARLEY COFFEE ORGANIC ONE LOVE ETHIOPIAN YIRGACHEFFE
  • 8 Ounce Ground Coffee
  • 100% Ethiopian Yirgacheffe
  • Medium Bodied With Fruity, Aromatic And Winey Undertones
Check on Amazon →

“Organic” Overview

In the case of coffee, producers cannot use synthetic substances such as most pesticides, herbicides, and fertilizers. If coffee is labeled “organic,” at least 95 percent of the beans must have been grown under organic conditions. This also includes:

  • Actively managing their land to restore, maintain, and enhance local biodiversity
  • Working within the local environment without disrupting the balance of natural ecological systems
  • Using methods to minimize pollution in the air, water, and soil
  • Using traditional farming methods (eg. crop rotations) to manage weeds, pests, and soil health

For roasters, this involves putting the green “organic” beans in separate roasters to make sure they don’t come into contact with anything that a non-organic bean has even touched.

For you, that means using a grinder and brewing mechanism that has either been VERY thoroughly washed or has never encountered non-organic blends. Otherwise, the brew is technically non-organic by the time you drink it (Though this does not impact certification).

De-Mystifying Pesticides

Before we jump into our recommendations for those of you wanting to buy organic, we need to have a very important discussion about pesticides.

Can certified organic products use pesticides?

Yes, and, in fact, the use of pesticides is pretty necessary for successful plant growth. However, these pesticides must be natural, rather than synthetic. Unfortunately, there is a widespread assumption that naturally-derived=safer for the environment, which is not necessarily the case.

How do pesticides on coffee plants affect you, the coffee consumer?

First, you should note that, unlike with other farm products, the coffee fruit isn’t generally sold–just the beans. Those beans are protected by the thick skin of the fruit. That means the pesticides and agrochemicals that you would get from other non-organic produce are unlikely to ever get to the part you are consuming. Furthermore, coffee beans are roasted, often at temperatures around 400°F. So even if some of those chemicals did make it to the bean, they’d be purged during the roasting.

However, while you won’t be affected by the pesticides used, the employees of coffee farms and the surrounding communities ARE impacted. And that is what you should be concerned about.

Talking Toxicity

ALL pesticides, every last one of them, are toxic. And while synthetic pesticides are often designed to target specific specifies to protect crops, natural pesticides cannot be tailored. So while a synthetic pesticide may only be harmful to destructive insects, its natural alternative may cause more widespread harm to the environment. This is especially problematic when considering how runoff impacts water-based ecosystems.

On the other hand, some synthetic pesticides are known to be carcinogens, teratogens, or mutagens, which is an issue for the workers. However, NOT all synthetic pesticides contain these.

What does it all mean?

So the take away here is that if you are going organic for environmental or humanitarian concerns, you’ll need to do more research than just checking for a label. There are plenty of non-organic and organic options that take steps to make sure their farming practices are safe for both the environment and their employees, you just have to do a little digging.

Best Organic Coffee

Now for the part that many of you came to this article for–the recommendations. These are brands and products that we have gone ahead and researched for you. So you can rest assured that their missions and practices are in the best interest of both the environment and their workers, in addition to the product being USDA Certified Organic.

Lifeboost Coffee

One of our favorite organic coffee brands right now is Lifeboost coffee. Their single-origin Nicaraguan is available in light, medium, and dark roast levels as well as a decaf.

Lifeboost Coffee
Lifeboost Coffee
Our rating:

Enjoy delicious, healthy, single origin, chemical-free, non-GMO coffee from small farms in the mountains of Nicaragua


In addition to being USDA certified organic, these coffee beans are non-GMO, fair trade, exceptionally low-acid, kosher, slow-roasted, hand-picked, and shade-grown. The coffee farm is situated 5700 ft above sea level, making for a pretty unique combination of high-quality attributes.

All in all, the craftsmanship comes together in a rich, mellow coffee with irresistible hints of caramel.

Sightglass Coffee Organic Toketee

Toketee Sight Glass
Sightglass Coffee Organic Toketee
Our rating:

You’re fancy, huh? So is this elevated take on the classic drip, blend. It’s carefully curated, seasonally rotating, and of course—cultured.


If you’re scrolling through this article, chances are you’re looking for a new bag of beans to run through your trusty drip brewer. That’s why we’re recommending Sightglass Coffee’s Organic Toketee blend. It’s marketed as “an elevated take on the classic drip blend,” so if you start every day with a plain cup of joe, you’ll love this stuff. 

To create this blend, Sightglass Coffee roasters combines beans from the Pacific as well as Central and South America (note that the coffee used rotates seasonally). They’re heated to medium-dark roast perfection before being prepped for delivery to your doorstep. Close your eyes and savor every sip of this brew, and see if you can pick out all of the flavor notes — there’s apricot, cacao nib, and caramel!

Caffe Vita Organic French Roast

Cafe Vita French Roast
Caffe Vita Organic French Roast
Our rating:

Big-bodied and sweet, this dark-roasted blend features plenty of roastiness with a chocolaty body and caramel sweetness to bring it all together.


If you’re anything like us (and you must be, Roasty reader, since you’ve found yourself on our site), you love a good French roasted brew. And one that’s organic, too? Oh, yeah. Put us down for a bag of those beans!

This blend of Central and South American, Indonesian, and African coffees meets both the above prerequisites, having been roasted to smoky, burnt French coffee perfection and grown with organic practices. The big-bodied brew is slightly sweet with notes of cocoa, maple syrup, and nutmeg — good enough to be enjoyed on its own, but still delicious with a splash of milk.

Death Wish Coffee

Not only is Death Wish Coffee organic, but the company also has Fair Trade practices. It is of blended origin and includes both Arabica and Robusta beans for the sake of caffeination. Oh yeah, did we mention it is touted as the most caffeinated coffee in the world? Their mission statement also includes a commitment to sustainability, a conscious choice that they go into depth about here.

With Death Wish, not only do you get a surprisingly smooth cup with much less bitterness than its competitors, but you also get a company that is committed to ethical engagement in the coffee market.

Kicking Horse Coffee

Kicking Horse is a Canadian company committed not only to producing 100% organic products but also 100% Fair Trade Certified products. Being “awake” to the concerns of and their impact upon the world around them is #1 in their core values statement. Their website also includes a list of notable causes and programs that they actively support.

As for the coffee itself, we’re happy to recommend the two following medium roasts.

The Smart Ass blend includes 100% Arabica beans sourced from Africa, Central America, and South America. It has the characteristic sweet, bright flavors of a great medium roast. Additionally, it is described as having redcurrant notes with hints of sugar cane and milk chocolate, with a “honeyed berry” body.

We have also included the Three Sisters blend because, honestly, we couldn’t help ourselves. The beans are sourced from Indonesia, Central, and South America, and they come together to create a beautifully complex, well-rounded brew. You’ll find notes of sweet tobacco, stone fruit, and cocoa.

Camano Island Coffee Organic Sumatra

Camano Island Coffee Roasters is a brand that is openly committed to ethical, sustainable practices. Their “About us” page is dedicated to breaking down exactly how they do that. In addition to being a Fair Trade and Certified Organic company, they also partner with Argos and Food4Farmers nonprofit. A portion of all their sales is donated to those organizations.

As for the coffee itself, you won’t be disappointed. The organic Sumatra is 100% Arabica, single-origin dark to medium-dark roast. It makes a robust brew with dried fruit flavor complemented by slightly smoky notes and hints of caramel.

Tiny Footprint Organic Cold Brew Coffee

On Sale

Tiny Footprint Coffee claims to be a “carbon negative” company because, for every bag sold and shipped, they donate a portion of the money to plant trees in Ecuador’s Mindo Cloud Forest. Not only are their reforestation efforts admirable, but they also have organic, fair-trade, and Rain Forest Alliance certified coffee. What’s more, they also make an effort to vet and purchase from other small, family-owned farms that are not fair-trade eligible.

Now for the coffee. We picked this one because an organic cold brew blend is something that struck us as rather unique. It’s 100% Arabica and features a mix of light and dark roasts from Ethiopia. You’ll notice the coffee has floral, fruity, and cocoa notes.

Cameron’s Coffee Organic French Roast

Cameron’s coffee is dedicated to social responsibility in their sustainable sourcing, humanitarian efforts, and environmental awareness. They use natural pest management and fertilization with a commitment to protecting biodiversity and land stewardship. Additionally, they roast in small batches to reduce water consumption.

The coffee itself is a dark roast perfect for a French press. It has a classic coffee vibe with a rich, smooth profile.

Marley Coffee Organic One Love Ethiopian YirgaCheffe

In addition to being certified organic, Marley Coffee is Fair Trade Certified. They also aid in deforestation and their single-use pods are completely recyclable. How’s that for sustainability! The coffee itself is medium-bodied with fruity, aromatic, and winey undertones.

If you’re looking for an ethically sourced Ethiopian YirgaCheffee coffee that is available in whole bean form, try Coffee Bean Direct’s Coffee Bean Direct Dark Ethiopian Yirgacheffe, Organic Fair Trade Whole Bean Coffee, 5-Pound Bag Organic Fair Trade dark roast.

The Bean Coffee Organic Mocha Java

The Bean Coffee Company is a family-owned business that offers 100% organic coffee that is also CCOF certified. Their among their core values is a dedicated responsibility to their customers, employees, global partnerships, families, and the environment. They also use small-batch roasting and 100% Arabica beans.

The medium roast has a rich, delicious complexity created by a blend of Arabian mocha with Indonesian java. It has a fuller body with a blended balance of acidity.

Ethical Bean Sweet Espresso

Our next Organic recommendation is so committed to their ethics that they put the word in their name. Ethical Bean’s four-pillar outlook prioritizes serving the community, practicing Fair Trade, ensuring quality products, and recognizing their responsibility to their producers as well as the environment.

Their sweet espresso is rather unique as far as espresso goes. It’s a medium-dark roast with a full, velvety body. Their website even specifically mentions that it “marries beautifully with milk.” So if you’re looking for the perfect base for your cappuccinos and lattes, this might be it! However, if you’re looking to serve it as a straight shot, for what’s worth, it also has a nice crema.

Additionally, if you like the brand but not the brew, their homepage has some lovely animations to communicate the feel of each one they offer. It’s both convenient and aesthetically pleasing.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the benefits of going organic?


100% USDA certified organic coffee supposedly contains more vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants that boost the immune system. However, these properties at some level are common to all coffee. So, while organic coffee doesn’t necessarily have any exclusive health benefits, coffee in general certainly does.


One of the main environmental benefits of organic coffee over conventional coffee is the reduction of deforestation. Organic coffee can thrive with more canopy cover than other conventional coffee, meaning forests, with their native wildlife and vegetation, can be conserved. Additionally, many certified organic companies donate to organizations that actively attempt to reverse the effects of deforestation.

Another benefit of leaving these ecosystems largely intact is that natural pest-deterrents/predators, including birds and lizards, remain undisturbed. This helps to reduce the need for large amounts of pesticides. Also, bird droppings, leaf litter, and natural decay serve as natural fertilizers to the coffee plants.

In the end, these factors help maintain the organic production system as it becomes sustainable and logistically feasible to exclusively use natural products to promote growth. Additionally, growers are encouraged to be actively aware of their environmental impact.


Many farmers who can go through the trouble to become certified organic producers are also able to afford to be fair trade compliant. Furthermore, organic arabica beans are quality checked by three different certification programs: Quality Assurance, Fair Trade, and Smithsonian Institution.

Furthermore, some proponents claim that organic practices are better for maintaining long-term soil health. However, this does largely depends on what exactly farmers are or are not using for their plants.

What is the certification process like?

For the sake of simplicity, we will be talking about USDA certification.  However, you should know that there are other organic certifications in different regions that have separate certification processes.

To be USDA certified a farmer must have been practicing complete organic-approved production for at least three years. That means no non-organic agrochemicals or pesticides for at least that period. Then, the rest of the supply chain must also be certified as having proper, organic-friendly practices. For roasters, that involves having specifically dedicated roasting equipment as to not “contaminate” the organic beans.

Unfortunately, for small-batch roasters, it is difficult to have separate equipment for that purpose. So many will opt to either only produce organic coffees or simply forgo the entire organic market altogether.

Does organic = sustainable?

The short answer is: no, not necessarily. While many companies that go through the effort to obtain the “organic” label do take conscious steps to also make other parts of their production sustainable, the certification has no requirements to promote or enforce these practices.

Therefore, there is no guarantee that a certified organic brand also has financially, socially, or entirely environmentally sustainable. In fact, often using organic fertilizer creates a larger carbon footprint than simply using safe practices with conventional fertilizer.

A Better Way to Vet Your Coffee

As you may have probably figured out, the organic label doesn’t exactly mean what everyone thinks it does. In some cases, it doesn’t even mean what companies advertise it as being. So how do you know if the beans you are buying were produced in an environmentally and ethically conscious manner?

What we’ve learned through years of engaging with the coffee industry is that the best way to get high-quality coffee that you can feel good about sipping on is to just do your research. By coming here, you have a great start! But you don’t have to take our or anyone else’s word for it.

We’ve linked to each company’s website so that you can apply the information provided here to determine for yourself if their mission is one you’re comfortable with supporting. Even if you can’t find a list of exactly what pesticides they’re using, you can usually tell by how they present their company in other areas whether their practices are worth supporting.

As a general rule of thumb, sticking to small-batch roasters and micro-lots is a good bet. Also, looking for how closely they deal with farmers and even their choices on packaging materials can give you great hints on where they stand on these important issues.

Happy Caffeinating!


Share the goods

Recommended Reads

Brew like a Barista
from home

The Home Barista Coffee Course 14-lesson video course about brewing consistently amazing coffee at home. Stream or download the entire course to learn how to make coffee as good as your local barista for a fraction of the cost.

Learn more