Buying Guides

The Best Decaf K-Cups

Just so you know, if you click on a product on RoastyCoffee.com and decide to buy it, we may earn a small commission.

Keurig K-cup coffee machines are convenient and versatile. They’re capable of producing just about any classic flavor of coffee that you can imagine, and all you have to do is pop in a K-cup single-serve pod and let the hot water flow.

The options are endless, and if you’ve made the switch to decaffeinated coffee to lower your caffeine intake for health reasons or are simply looking for the perfect pods for a slight afternoon pick-me-up, you’re sure to find a pod that fits your needs. 

Don’t think that just because you’re using a single-serve type of coffee maker, you can’t get delicious decaf options in all kinds of flavors, roast levels, and varieties.

Check out the list below for our favorite high-quality decaf coffee K-cups that will give die-hard coffee drinkers the satisfaction of a delicious cup of flavorful coffee without all the jitters of coffee made from a normal K-cup!

At a Glance: The Best Decaf K-Cups For Your Keurig Machine

best decaf k cups

Our Picks: The Best Decaf K-Cups for Your Keurig

Quick Summary: The Best Decaf K-Cups For Your Keurig Machine

Maud's Dark Roast Decaf Coffee (Decaf Tall Dark and Handsome) 100ct. Solar Energy Produced Recyclable Single Serve Decaf Dark Roast Coffee Pods, 100% Arabica Coffee California Roasted, KCup CompatibleMaud's Dark Roast Tall Dark and Handsome Decaf Coffee
  • 100% Arabica
  • Decaf Dark Roast
  • 100% Recyclable Coffee Pods
Check on Amazon →
SF Bay Coffee OneCUP DECAF French Roast 80 Ct Natural Water Processed Dark Roast Compostable Coffee Pods, K Cup Compatible including Keurig 2.0San Francisco Bay Coffee Decaf French Roast Compostable Coffee Pods
  • Dark Roast
  • 80 Count
  • Dark roast
Check on Amazon →
Krispy Kreme Classic Decaf, Single-Serve Keurig K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee Pods, 72 CountKrispy Kreme Classic Medium Roast Decaf Single-Serve Keurig K-Cup Pods
  • 72 Count
  • Medium Roast
  • 100% Arabica
Check on Amazon →
Caribou Coffee Caribou Blend Decaf, Single-Serve Keurig K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee, 96 CountCaribou Coffee Caribou Blend Decaf Medium Roast Keurig K-Cup Pods
  • Medium Roast
  • 96 Count
  • Decaffeinated coffee
Check on Amazon →
The Original Donut Shop Decaf Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee, 96 CountThe Original Donut Shop Decaf Medium Roast Keurig K-Cup Pods
  • 96 Count
  • Medium Roast Coffee
  • Recyclable K-cup pods
Check on Amazon →
Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Dark Magic Decaf, Single-Serve Keurig K-Cup Pods, Dark Roast Coffee, 72 CountGreen Mountain Coffee Roasters Dark Magic Decaf Single-Serve Keurig K-Cup Pods
  • 72 Count
  • Dark Roast Coffee
  • 100% Arabica
Check on Amazon →
McCafe Decaf Premium Medium Roast K-Cup Coffee Pods 84 CountMcCafe Decaf Premium Medium Roast K-Cup Coffee Pods
  • 84 Count
  • Medium Roast Coffee
  • 100% Arabica beans
Check on Amazon →
Dunkin Donuts Dunkin Decaf K-Cups (24 Count)Dunkin' Decaf Medium Roast K-Cup Pods
  • 24 Count
  • Medium Roast Coffee
  • Orthodox Union Kosher
Check on Amazon →

Maud’s Dark Roast Tall Dark and Handsome

If you love a good dark roast blend and don’t want to sacrifice the natural flavors and quality when it comes to decaf coffee, then Maud’s is a sure bet. It’s a fantastic example of water-processed decaf done right, with none of the chemicals you’d find in standard decaf. 

Things We Like: 

  • The dark roast coffee offers a deep, rich, and bold flavor that you’ll be surprised came from a pod! 
  • The coffee is made from 100% arabica Swiss Water Process beans, meaning you’re getting a quality, all-natural, chemical-free cup with every pod. 
  • The coffee pods are 100% recyclable, which is a huge plus!

Things We Don’t Like:

  • There are some quality control problems with the pods, and your Keurig machine may have a hard time piercing through the top foil, causing the pod to “explode” during brewing. It’s a real shame considering the quality of the coffee. 

San Francisco Bay Coffee Decaf French Roast 

San Francisco Bay’s decaf offering is bold and unique, but the packaging is even more so. With a distinctive eco-friendly pod design and a commitment to only sending out fresh-roasted coffee from Central and South America, you’ll love reaching for these K-cups in the morning. 

Things We Like: 

  • We love that these pods are completely commercially compostable and eco-friendly! Have your coffee and feel guilt-free about the environmental impact of the pods!
  • The coffee is roasted and packaged fresh from the manufacturer to ensure a balanced taste. 
  • The coffee’s rich flavor profile is amazingly strong and bold for a K-cup. 

Things We Don’t Like:

  • The packaging has some quality control issues: the concave tops are not uniform, so sometimes the Keurig machine has trouble piercing through the foil. 
  • Since they’re not sealed like standard K-cups, the pods can lose freshness if left out in the open. They should be sealed in an airtight bag to stay fresh. 

Krispy Kreme Classic Medium Roast Decaf K-Cup Pods

On Sale

There’s nothing like a Krispy Kreme donut, except maybe their delicious coffee. The decaf coffee pods from Krispy Kreme deliver a bold, smooth flavor that doesn’t quit; you might not even believe that it’s decaf! 

Things We Like: 

  • These pods pack a smooth, bold taste that pairs amazingly well with donuts! The medium roast coffee is an excellent balance between light roast decaf coffee and dark, without the bitter taste or acidity that you may get from a breakfast blend. 
  • These pods come from a trusted brand; Krispy Kreme has been around since the 1930s and knows how to make a great, classic cup of coffee. 

Things We Don’t Like:

  • The Decaf pods don’t taste exactly like the standard, store-bought Krispy Kreme decaf, which can be disappointing if that’s what you’re used to. 
  • The K-cups are not recyclable or eco-friendly. 

Caribou Coffee Caribou Blend Decaf Pods

This medium roast high-quality coffee has a robust flavor and syrupy taste without being overpowering and is a great option to reach for during the morning rush. Just pop it into the machine, and you’ve got a delicious brew of creamy coffee in seconds.

Like Free Coffee? Get your first bag free with an Atlas Coffee World Tour Click here to get the deal

Even better, this decaf blend is Swiss Water processed and Rainforest Alliance Certified, so you can feel good about reaching for an organic and environmentally-friendly cup of full-bodied coffee. 

Things We Like: 

  • This decaf coffee is all-natural and chemical-free, so you’ll enjoy a delicious cup without the bitter aftertaste.
  • The excellent flavor is bold and rich enough that you can brew a large cup of coffee without the brew becoming too weak!

Things We Don’t Like:

  • While the flavor is there, it’s not the same as the drip coffee you can expect in-store at a Caribou location, which is a bit of a bummer.
  • These cups come at a higher price point than much of the competition.

The Original Donut Shop Decaf Medium Roast K-Cup Pods

There’s nothing like a no-fuss cup of Donut Shop coffee. This is Keurig’s offering in the K-cup space, and it’s a delicious one.

This classic roast gives off nostalgic diner-coffee notes without bitterness or burnt taste. It’s a safe and versatile option that tastes great on its own or customized with all the cream, sugar, or syrup your heart desires!

Things We Like: 

  • The aroma of this coffee is divine and will make your mouth water before you even get a chance to sip it!
  • The brew is bold and dark, with no unpleasant aftertaste. It goes down smooth and can easily be enjoyed in black. 
  • This coffee is an excellent value and reasonably priced for the number of pods you get in a package. The quality of the coffee is excellent for the price!

Things We Don’t Like:

  • You may find a problem with coffee grinds in your coffee, which is a disappointment because the issue is not with the coffee itself but with quality control on the cups. 

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Dark Magic Decaf Pods

On Sale

Green Mountain is an unassuming brand that offers a no-fuss cup of coffee, but you may be surprised at just how bold their decaf offering can be!

This brew is not for the faint of heart, but those who love a strong coffee (regardless of caffeine content) will jump for joy over these dark roast decaf K-cups! With all the flavor and none of the bitterness, this coffee is an excellent value for the price! 

Things We Like: 

  • With a deep, intense taste, this coffee is excellent served black and an ideal base for additives. 
  • The green mountain brand is committed to becoming 100% sustainable, responsibly sourced, and Fair Trade, which is a big plus if you’re environmentally conscious or concerned with labor rights.  
  • The price is unbeatable for such a bold and flavorful cup of coffee!

Things We Don’t Like:

  • There have been some issues with quality control leading to weak seals on the foil top of the K-cups.
  • Coffee grounds have been known to leak from the pods. 

McCafe Decaf Premium Medium Roast K-Cup Coffee Pods

By far one of the most popular decaf K-cup options for coffee drinkers, there’s a reason these McCafe Premium medium roast single-serve coffee pods beat out other, more premium brands.

From the value to the strong, balanced, recognizable flavor of a McDonald’s cup of coffee, these pods aren’t fancy, but they’re a warm and comforting option when you reach for that second cup during the workday.

Things We Like: 

  • The familiar taste of a McDonald’s cup of coffee is still there, and it’s as bold as ever! 
  • These K-cups are an excellent value at such a low price point per cup! It’s a good low-priced alternative to more expensive house blends from its competitors.

Things We Don’t Like:

  • The pods use a paper filter on the inside, but the filter can become faulty and tear, causing grounds to be spilled into your cup. 

Dunkin’ Decaf Medium Roast K-Cup Pods

Why should you have to leave the house to get a great cup of Dunkin’ Donuts coffee? There are so many reasons Dunkin’ has become one of America’s favorite coffee shops, but one of them is their bold, distinct flavors!

These medium decaf K-cups are about as no-frills as you can get, and the coffee is versatile enough to be enjoyed black or with additives like sugar or syrup!

Things We Like: 

  • There’s no difference in flavor from the decaf coffee you’d get in-store at a Dunkin’ location!
  •  These K-cups make a very drinkable coffee without that bitter aftertaste that you may associate with decaf coffee. 

Things We Don’t Like:

  • You may find coffee grounds in the bottom of your cup with these pods, which is certainly not ideal.

Education 

What does it mean if my decaf coffee is “Swiss Water” decaf? 

Swiss Water Decaf processing is a natural process by which water is used to remove the caffeine from coffee beans before the roasting process begins. This method uses no chemicals, is certified organic, Fairtrade, Kosher, Halal, and is environmentally friendly.

It’s an all-natural alternative to the traditional method of decaffeinating coffee, where chemical solvents such as methylene chloride are used to strip the beans of the caffeine.

This method is safe, but there’s still a chance there will be trace amounts of the chemicals left over in the coffee. 

How do I make my Keurig Coffee taste the best that it can? 

There are several things you can do to help boost the flavor and quality of your Keurig Coffee.

For one, make sure your Keurig K-cup machine is routinely cleaned and descaled since mineral buildup can cause even the highest-quality coffee to taste bad. You can do this with plain white vinegar or commercially available descalers. 

Also, make sure you’re using water that isn’t full of minerals like calcium and lime since that can again affect your coffee taste. Store-bought drinking water is best. 

Another tip is to ensure that you’re not brewing with too much water. While we at Roasty Coffee love a good-sized cup, most Keurig K-cups can only handle about 8-12 ounces of water at the most before the coffee begins to weaken.

If you’re looking to fill up your travel mug or carafe, you’ll need to use more than one pod. 

I’ve heard some K-cups explode. How do I prevent that? 

Unfortunately, no design is perfect, and sometimes there can be issues with the pods properly brewing. Sometimes this is due to the manufacturer adding too much air into the pod. 

Other times, the coffee maker may not have pierced the foil properly, so the water pools around the pod instead of in it, causing it to “melt” or “burst.”

If there’s too much air, the best thing you can do to make sure that this doesn’t happen is to pierce the foil, then open the machine back up to allow any excess air to escape before closing your machine again and beginning the brew. 

If the foil on the top of your pod didn’t pierce correctly, simply take a fork, toothpick, or other small, sharp instrument and poke through the foil where the piercer should go. Then reinsert the pod back into the machine and close the lid. 

Frequently Asked Questions

Do K-cups have the same amount of caffeine as normal decaf? 

Yes, the K-cups contain around the same dose of caffeine as you would find in traditional decaf coffee beans, around 1-3% of the original caffeine amount. When you brew a decaf K-cup, you’ll only be ingesting trace amounts of caffeine, just like with a regular brew. 

Are K-cups cheaper than regular coffee? 

There’s a bit of a price spectrum here. K-cups are definitely cheaper over the long run than a cup of Starbucks, for example, but they’re a bit more expensive than buying your own beans or even pre-ground coffee. But it really just depends on how you prefer to get your coffee.

K-cups can vary in price depending on the brand and whether you buy them in bulk. Still, the average cost per cup seems to hover around $0.65, while regular drip coffee is somewhere around $0.25 per cup, meaning Keurig K-cups are about two or three times as expensive as a drip coffee.

However, if you routinely hit the coffee shop on your way to work, K-cups are an affordable option that will save you a fortune in the long run. 

Is decaf coffee better for you than regular coffee? 

There’s no reason to think that the decaf version of your favorite basic coffee is any better or worse for you than the caffeinated version, although there are some differences, mainly in how the coffee is made. 

For starters, caffeinated coffee can have some health benefits if taken in moderation, which you don’t get if you’re drinking decaf.

There are also a few health risks associated with decaf coffee made using robusta beans, which have been linked to increased cholesterol due to the higher fat content. If you’re drinking decaf coffee and are worried about health risks, we recommend choosing 100% arabica beans. 

Conclusion

When choosing the best decaf K-cup pod for your household, make sure you consider the roast level and coffee flavor. You should also consider how eco-friendly the pods are if your environmental footprint is an important factor.

There are many brands out there that offer recyclable or compostable pods. 

It’s also important to make sure you know exactly how to work your Keurig K-cup coffee maker and all the quirks associated with it so that you can brew the best cup possible.

The more water you use, the weaker your cup of coffee will be. For instance, a K-cup will usually only brew a strong cup for 8 to 12 ounces at most. If you want extra coffee, it’s time to add a new pod!

The best part about decaf K-cups is that it’s easy for coffee fans to experiment with new flavors and brands to find that brew that works perfectly for you without the effects of caffeine! So, dear coffee lover, do your research and be open to trying new things! 

Happy (de)Caffeinating!

Share the goods

Recommended Reads

  • Coffee Facts

    Keurig 2.0: Brew Settings 1-6 Explained

    Check out the Keurig 2.0 brew settings 1-6 explained so you can start brewing your favorite joe with the K-carafe or other coffee cups!

  • Coffee Facts

    Does Your Reusable K-Cup Brew Weak Coffee?

    If your reusable K-Cup brewing weak coffee? Find out for more on how to strengthen your caffeinated (or decaffeinated) cup!

  • Buying Guides

    The Best K-Cups For A Keurig

    Interested in purchasing new K-Cups for your Keurig? We've compiled a list of the best K-Cups that fit your taste and budget.

  • Coffee Facts

    Keurig Coffee Maker Problems

    Keurigs can be convenient and easy-to-use for any home of coffee lovers, but they come with their problems. Check out our tips on how to best solve these issues.

  • Coffee Facts

    Does Decaf Coffee Dehydrate You?

    So, does decaf coffee dehydrate you? We've taken a deeper look into on of your favorite drinks to let you know!

  • Coffee Facts

    Is Decaf Coffee a Diuretic?

    So, is decaf coffee a diuretic? We did some research on this subject so you can find out the answers from us!

Brew like a Barista
from home

The Home Barista Coffee Course 14-lesson video course about brewing consistently amazing coffee at home. Stream or download the entire course to learn how to make coffee as good as your local barista for a fraction of the cost.

Like Free Coffee? Get your first bag free with an Atlas Coffee World Tour Click here to get the deal
Learn more