Buying Guides

Best Decaf Coffee: The Secrets Behind the Brew

Just so you know, if you click on a product on and decide to buy it, we may earn a small commission.

If you are here, it is pretty obvious that you love coffee. After all, coffee is one of the most popular beverages across the globe. However, not everyone enjoys that energy boost that coffee gives them.

Coffee, as you no doubt know, contains caffeine. It is that caffeine content that gives you that pick me up that you need to get moving in the morning (or even the afternoon). Some people, though, whether due to health reasons or just simply personal choice seek to limit their caffeine intake in a given day. For them, decaffeinated coffee is an excellent way to still enjoy that cup of joe without ingesting that extra caffeine.

If that sounds like you, read on for our top picks for the best decaf coffee on the market as well as some insider information on how decaffeinated coffee actually works. 

The Truth About Decaffeinated Coffee

What Is Decaffeinated Coffee?

This may sound like a silly question, but you would be surprised how many people really don’t know. Decaffeinated coffee is regular coffee that has gone through a process to remove almost all the caffeine from the beans. In most cases, about 97% of the caffeine will be removed. The end result is a cup of coffee that won’t give you that morning pick me up or any of the other side effects of caffeine.

How Is It Made?

So how is decaffeinated coffee produced? There are a few different processes, although most of them are, in the end, very similar to one another. Basically, the coffee beans are washed in a solvent that is usually made up of water, organic solvents or carbon dioxide. This solvent slowly removes the caffeine from the beans with the end result being a beautiful coffee bean that is caffeine-free.

This process occurs at the very beginning before the beans are ever roasted and/or ground. Here at Roasty Coffee we always recommend you buy whole bean coffee, and that recommendation extends to the decaffeinated coffee bean variety as well.

On Sale

Can You Tell a Difference?

This is the big one. Most people are very picky when it comes to their coffee, so if they decide to switch to decaf coffee that want to make sure they get a coffee that tastes very similar to the regular caffeinated variety.

I will tell you, that the decaf process does impact the overall smell and taste of the coffee. More often than not decaffeinated coffee will have a much milder taste and smell compared to regular coffee. So how do you get around this? In my opinion, if your decaf coffee is too mild in both smell and taste, you should go with an overall stronger bean that has been decaffeinated in order to better reach that level of strength you are looking for in a cup of coffee.

You may have to experiment when you first switch to decaffeinated coffee at first. However, with the right roaster and source of beans you should be able to find decaf coffee that tastes very similar to that regular cup of joe you have been enjoying for so many years now.

Roasty’s Top Picks: Decaf Coffee

Seattle’s Best Coffee Decaf Portside Blend

We’re starting off strong with Seattle’s Best Decaf Portside Blend. Previously known as Decaf Signature Blend, this brew has been around the block and never disappoints.

This Seattle’s Best is a medium roast coffee that brews a hearty, well-balanced brew with a smooth, full body. The beans are 100% Latin American Arabica, and the brew is rigorously and thoroughly tested throughout processing to ensure consistency. 

If you are looking for a tried and true decaf brew to go down easy, the Portside Blend is for you. We like this brew because despite being a decaf, you don’t lose any of the punchiness of your morning coffee. So, your coffee craving will be satisfied without any help from caffeine. 

Kicking Horse Coffee Decaf

Looking for something a little darker and perhaps a bit bolder? Try Kicking Horse Coffee’s Dark Roast Decaf. 

Kicking Horse‘s Dark Roast Decaf is sourced from Central and South American and utilizes exclusively shade-grown Arabica beans. They use the swiss water process to decaffeinate their beans, so you aren’t losing any richness in flavor. 

To top of the great taste of this brew, the beans are certified organic, fair trade, and kosher. So you can savor the notes of roasted hazelnuts and chocolate with full peace of mind.  

Waka Coffee Colombian Decaf

Now we know instant coffee might not be the first thing to come to mind when you think of quality coffee, but hear us out on this one. Waka Coffee really is bringing instant back. 

After Waka gave us a chance to test and review their brews, their coffees have been a necessary pantry staple. Their decaf consists of medium roasted, single-origin Colombian Arabica beans. They use a natural Sugar Cane EA decaffeination process and freeze-drying for creating their signature instant coffee, so you know you’re getting top-notch stuff. 

The brew has a classic, balanced body with a subtle note of citrus, and we can confirm that the decaf is just as tasty as the full-caf version. Plus, 4% of their profits go to funding clean water projects through the “Add Water, Give Water” program. 

Volcanica Costa Rica Tarrazu Decaf

If you’ve been around the coffee scene at all, the name Volcanica should sound pretty familiar to you. This brand has basically become synonymous with high-quality, accessible coffee, and their decaf does not disappoint. 

Their Costa Rica Decaf Tarrazu is a single-origin medium roast sourced from the southern mountainous region of San Jose. The beans are decaffeinated using Swiss Water Processing (100% chemical-free process that prioritizes flavor). 

These beans make for a truly unique and enjoyable decaf brew. It is full-bodied and smooth with a subtle chocolate flavor with notes of crisp, toasted apple.

No Fun Jo Decaf

This decaf by Jo is anything but no fun. With a brew that is complex and flavorful, this won’t be your average cup of joe. 

This is another whole bean Arabica coffee; however, this is a blended coffee, using beans from the top 2% of all Arabica raw coffee worldwide through direct sourcing. Like many of Jo’s coffees, the decaf is USDA certified organic, Fair Trade Certified, and Kosher Certified. In addition, it is decaffeinated by Swiss Water Processing.

No Fun Jo Decaf is a medium-dark roast, so the resulting brew has a decadent, full body with complementary notes of sweet blueberry and milk chocolate. 

Don Pablo Colombian Decaf Light Roast

Looking for something a bit lighter? Don Pablo‘s Colombian Decaf has you covered.

While many people may be familiar with Don Pablo’s Medium-Dark roast decaf, they also offer this lighter roast (close to a medium to medium-light roast). These beans are roasted 18°F cooler than the standard roast, leaving you with a light and mild brew with notes of caramel, cocoa, and citrus. 

Additionally, the beans are 100% Arabica and small-batch roasted with considerably low acidity for a lighter roast coffee. They are decaffeinated using Swiss Water Processing, so they are nearly caffeine-free.

Stone Street Mayan Water Decaf

Last but certainly not least, we have this offering from Stone Street Coffee Co. 

Mayan Water Decaf is subtle and earthy, lending it a flavor profile that stands out in this lineup. The beans are medium roasted, leaving you with a modest body and full flavor. Also, as you may have guessed with water in the name, these are Swiss Water Processed. 

Additionally, this blend of Central American coffees is Rainforest Alliance certified and Kosher. The brand also partners with Sweet Unit Farms to utilize direct trade methods for ensuring sustainability as well as social and environmental responsibility. 

Is There Caffeine in Decaf Coffee?

It is important for you to remember that just because it is called decaffeinated coffee, doesn’t mean that there is absolutely no caffeine in it whatsoever. While the process they use to make the coffee does wipe away most of the caffeine, some always remain.

The amount of caffeine will vary from coffee to coffee. However, you can pretty much bet that the amount of caffeine in your decaf coffee will be somewhere between 0-7 mg per cup. To put that into perspective, the average cup of regular coffee contains somewhere between 70-140 mg of caffeine per cup. As you can see, almost all the caffeine is removed.

Still, if you are looking to completely eliminate caffeine from your diet, unfortunately, you are going to have to give up your daily habit. But if you want to almost eliminate it, then you can stick with your cup of decaf coffee every day and you will ingest very little caffeine.

Is Decaf coffee bad for you?

Given all of the resentment aimed at decaf within the coffee community, you may be wondering if there are any negative side effects of reaching for decaffeinated coffee. 

Well, according to this 2017 study published by The BMJ, the answer seems to be no, there are not negative side effects to choosing decaf. However, the idea that decaf could actually be bad for your health is not completely unfounded. 

Why People Are Concerned

As we mentioned earlier, in order to decaffeinate coffee beans, they must be exposed to a solvent that rids them of the substance. While sometimes these substances are labelled as “natural” or “organic” because they are naturally occurring, they are often synthetically produced. This is a common practice with ethyl acetate, which can pose some risk at high doses. 

But, the amount present in coffee is negligible and unlikely to pose issues. Another substance that has been a source of concern is methylene chloride as exposure to it in an airborne form can impact the central nervous system, reducing attention and coordination.

However, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has cleared it to be used for decaffeination so long as there is less than .0001% in the final product. So, this is also nothing to be worried about.

Looking Forward

Nonetheless, scientists continue to investigate potential health benefits and draw backs of both caffeinated and decaffeinated coffee. Some current research involves investigating the varied impact of high decaffeinated coffee consumption on HDL2 (a type of cholesterol) levels across different BMI  ranges. 

Now, let’s take a look at the potential health benefits of decaffeinated coffee.

So…Is Decaf Good For You?

We have already learned that coffee does have many health benefits, and it turns out that those health benefits aren’t eliminated just because you switch to decaf.


Like regular coffee, decaffeinated coffee is loaded with nutrients your body needs and it is filled with antioxidants that you need for a healthy life. However, there are some differences between regular coffee and decaf.

For example, decaf coffee can have up to 15% lower amounts of the antioxidants hydrocinnamic acid and polyphenols compared to regular coffee. Still, that is not a significant amount in the grand scheme of things. So if you are looking to lower your caffeine intake, don’t think you will have to completely give up many of the health benefits in coffee.

Reduced Risk of Disease

Like regular coffee, decaf coffee can actually reduce your risk of developing type 2 diabetes and both types can actually improve liver function and even prevent premature death. Some studies have even linked both regular coffee and decaf to the reduced risk of developing a variety of neurodegenerative disorders and it could even help reduce the risk of Parkinson’s disease and Alzheimer’s disease.

Also, studies have shown that if you drink two or more cups of decaffeinated coffee a day, you will have up to a 48% lower chance of developing rectal cancer.

No Acid Reflux or Crash

Additionally, one of the main side effects of drinking coffee is heartburn or acid reflux. When you drink decaf, however, those side effects are greatly reduced. Plus, without the caffeine, you won’t need to worry about getting tired after the caffeine runs its course.  

While overall regular coffee does seem to have a bit of an advantage, many of these same health benefits can also be found in decaf coffee and there are even a few additional benefits to add to it, meaning that there are many great reasons for drinking decaf that go far beyond just the desire to lower your caffeine intake in a given day.

Who Should Drink Decaf Coffee?

So the question becomes, who should drink decaffeinated coffee? Should we all do it? Look, if you want to drink decaf coffee, by all means go for it. It definitely won’t hurt you and in some ways it may help you.

Still, there are others out there that probably should choose decaf over regular coffee. Some people are just more sensitive to the side effects of caffeine than others. It can leave them feeling anxious and jittery or even keep them up late into the night. In fact, those with anxiety disorders should probably avoid caffeine.

Depending on your situation, it could be your doctor who recommends limiting your caffeine intake – such as women who are pregnant, the elderly, and those with heart conditions.

Obviously, we’re not you’re doctor – but be sure to pay attention to how caffeine affects your body and maybe try moving to decaf if you’re overdoing it with caffeine. 

Wrapping Up

Now you understand the difference between regular and decaf coffee, and not just the superficial details about it either. Knowing this can help you find the perfect decaf coffee if you decide to reduce or even eliminate your caffeine intake each day. Remember, just because you want to limit your caffeine, doesn’t mean you have to give up your favorite cup of coffee.

While you may have to experiment to find the perfect decaffeinated coffee, I encourage you to keep searching until you find one that you like as much as your regular cup of joe. Caffeine is considered relatively harmless in reasonable doses. However, there are still many people that want to reduce how much they have in a day.

And there is nothing wrong with that! Finding the right kind of decaf coffee can be the key for all coffee lovers to reduce their caffeine while still getting to enjoy a great cup of coffee.

Just because its decaf doesn’t mean it is bad. But you will have to try different kinds to find one that works for you. Are you ready to reduce the caffeine in your diet? Then why not start by beginning your search for a great cup of decaffeinated coffee today.

Happy Caffeinating!

Share the goods

Recommended Reads

Brew like a Barista
from home

The Home Barista Coffee Course 14-lesson video course about brewing consistently amazing coffee at home. Stream or download the entire course to learn how to make coffee as good as your local barista for a fraction of the cost.

Learn more