Buying Guides

Mistobox Coffee Review: A High-Quality Subscription Service

Are you curious about the MistoBox buzz? Our coffee subscription review spills the beans! We’re big fans of MistoBox, but only you can decide if it’s right for you. Read on to learn all about it!

Just so you know, if you click on a product on and decide to buy it, we may earn a small commission.

We highly recommend regularly receiving coffee subscription boxes at your doorstep. The excitement of receiving flavorful, often exclusive coffee selections from around the world at your front door never fades.

Keep MistoBox in mind as you weigh coffee subscription options. It’s a popular pick among coffee lovers, as the company offers a variety of coffees and roasting options. Subscribers also rave about MistoBox’s efficiency, reliability, and dedication to providing customers with high-quality coffee.

We tell you everything you need to know about MistoBox in our review below. Plus, we give you all our thoughts on whether or not Roasty thinks it’s a worthwhile service. Spoiler alert: we do, but only for those with a serious coffee-drinking habit.

Mistobox Coffee Review

Save 25% On Your First Order – just use code “MBROASTY25” at checkout for any new subscription.  – Click here to get started

Key Takeaways

  • Founded by Connor Riley and Samantha Meis, MistoBox has grown from a Shark Tank pitch to a successful coffee subscription service with a wide range of coffees — we’re talking more than 500 of them! — from more than 50 roasters.
  • The subscription service provides immense variety, affordability, and flexibility in delivery schedules. Unfortunately, though, shipping fees are not included, and sampler packs are unavailable.
  • MistoBox could be a smart investment for avid coffee drinkers, offering savings over time and a chance to discover unique artisanal coffees. There are even gift options available to share with your fellow coffee lovers.

What Is MistoBox?

Founded in 2012 by Connor Riley and Samantha Meis, MistoBox began as a graduate school class project. After lots of planning and hard work, Riley and Meis pitched their idea to Shark Tank. Fast-forward to now. With an investment from Mark Cuban, a few tweaks to the company, 50 thousand customers, and almost 5 million dollars in profits later, MistoBox is here to stay.

Mistobox Coffee on table

How Does MistoBox Work?

MistoBox matches you with coffee options from around the world based on your preferences. Every batch of coffee is roasted to order, and the 12-ounce bag appears on your doorstep a few days later. Read on for a more detailed explanation of the process.

You Pick the Coffee

The first step in purchasing a MistoBox subscription is selecting what kinds of coffee you want to receive. Do this by teaching MistoBox about your preferences via a quick quiz or picking your beans with the MistoBox Brew Queue.

The quiz uses your answers to questions like, “How do you take your coffee?” and, “What is your favorite roast level?” to determine what bags of coffee beans you’re most likely to enjoy and how often you’ll receive them.

The Brew Queue is a tool that lets you create a list of coffees you’re interested in trying and in the order you want them shipped to you. Your coffee ships according to your list, and you can easily rearrange your selections whenever you want.

The hundreds of coffees available through MistoBox come from a range of roasters, some of whom are among the biggest and most well-known in the coffee community. A few MistoBox-partnered roasters you might recognize are 1000 Faces Coffee, Verve Coffee Roasters, and AKA Coffee Roasters.

Like Free Coffee? Get your first bag free with an Atlas Coffee World Tour Click here to get the deal

Select a Membership Tier

MistoBox offers three subscription tiers: Basic, Deluxe, and Exclusive.

Basic is the most standard level, and its goal is to provide customers with affordable, good-tasting coffee regularly. Deluxe is one step up, offering coffee aficionados some of the market’s more exquisite coffees. The Exclusive level is a notch above Deluxe, including access to limited roasts from some of the most well-known names in the business.

Your Coffee Ships

Once your selected beans have been roasted to perfection, they are packaged to seal in as much freshness as possible. Then, they make their way to your address.

This subscription service allows you to select your preferred delivery frequency, from once a week to every four weeks. You can edit or pause your delivery schedule at any time, and if you have an Alexa by Amazon, you can download your MistoBox info to your Amazon account and update your delivery settings by voice command.

The MistoBox Review at a Glance

Mistobox Coffee Review
Mistobox Coffee Subscription
Our rating:

Save 25% On Your First Order – just use code “MBROASTY25” at checkout for any new subscription.

Check Price

Things We Like

  • A wide variety of coffee
  • Access to expert coffee curators
  • Affordability
  • Flexibility

Room for Improvement

  • Shipping price excluded
  • No coffee samplers available

An In-Depth MistoBox Coffee Subscription Review

We see plenty of good in MistoBox, and that’s not surprising. The company has done an excellent job making sure customers get some of the highest quality coffee they can get their hands on.

MistoBox Coffee

Coffee Variety

One reason MistoBox holds such a high place on our list of favorite coffee subscription companies is that there is a pretty big selection of coffee for subscribers to enjoy. That’s the greatest advantage of receiving a subscription coffee box, accessing beans that aren’t easy to get.

With 500 different bags of coffee ordered from several different companies and more than 50 artisanal roasters, you’ll have more than enough joe to try. Additionally, MistoBox lets you choose between whole bean and pre-ground coffee and single-origin, bean blends, or espresso beans.

pouring MistoBox coffee into a wooden cup

Coffee Curators

Having a professional who knows the specifics of coffee quality, flavors, and roasting techniques can help coffee lovers experiment with their morning cups of coffee. One of MistoBox’s knowledgeable coffee curators can help you find exactly what you’re searching for, whether you’re new to the specialty coffee game and unsure where to start or just looking to try something different.

Affordable Prices

Another point in the MistoBox “Pro” column comes from its price points. As of January 2024, MistoBox subscriptions start at $12.71 plus shipping. That’s a pretty good deal, especially considering the huge variety of coffee beans you get access to.

Flexible Shipping Options

MistoBox leaves plenty of room for flexibility. See the Brew Queue for proof. That tool permits you to not only decide what kind of coffee beans — according to roast level, flavor profile, etc. — you’ll get. It also lets you choose the order in which you’ll receive each coffee bag.

Whether you use the Brew Queue or not, you can decide how often you receive your beans. MistoBox gives you four options: weekly, biweekly, every three weeks, or once every four weeks. Each of these options appeals to all different kinds of coffee drinkers, making MistoBox the right fit for a large chunk of people.

Shipping Costs Not Included

Unfortunately, the cost of a MistoBox subscription doesn’t automatically include shipping costs. The coffee itself is a great price, but the extra shipping fees per bag of joe might start doing some damage to your budget.

No Coffee Samplers

It’s always nice to order a few coffee samples before committing to a full-size bag. After all, your morning coffee routine is too sacred a ritual to risk ruining with beans you don’t love. Unfortunately, MistoBox does not let you try before you buy.

The company is confident that the guidance, support, and customer service provided by a coffee curator will help you find beans you’ll love. Chatting with a curator will be more useful than blindly testing coffee on your own, but it may not fully ease any prospective customers’ anxieties like a sampler box could.

MistoBox Gifts and Goodies

It’s worth noting that you can also gift subscriptions from MistoBox to fellow coffee lovers in your life.

Choose a batch of beans for your loved one based on their preferences. Or, if you don’t know what types of coffee they like best, let them choose their own through the Brew Queue. Then, once their coffee has been chosen, the beans are roasted, put into beautiful packaging, and shipped to their doorstep — it’s that easy!

Since you’re the gift-giver, you can choose how much coffee the recipient gets, ranging from two to 24 boxes. You can also decide how often they’ll receive future shipments and how long their subscription will last.

MistoBox also sells non-coffee gift options, like t-shirts, sweaters, mugs, and coffee thermoses!

What to Consider Before Buying a Coffee Subscription

Before splurging on MistoBox or any other coffee subscription service, take a moment to ponder a few things.

Mistobox Coffee Review
Mistobox Coffee Subscription
Our rating:

Save 25% On Your First Order – just use code “MBROASTY25” at checkout for any new subscription.

Check Price

Amount of Coffee and Delivery Frequency

The average coffee drinker in America consumes about three cups per day. How much coffee do you drink daily? Weekly? Monthly?

The answers to those questions will help you determine if a coffee subscription makes sense for you and, if so, how often you’ll need to receive coffee shipments. If you rarely consume the beverage, having boxes of coffee delivered to your door regularly probably isn’t the best idea.

If you drink at least six cups a week, you might be able to justify getting a MistoBox delivery every four weeks. If you’re drinking more than that, though, you probably need to look into receiving coffee more frequently.

Price Range

Take a look at your budget and figure out how much you can afford to spend on high-quality coffee selections.

The cost of buying a coffee subscription service might seem steep at first, but one of them can save you hundreds of dollars if you’ve been frequenting a coffee shop every day. Plus, think of the other benefits you get. Nine times out of 10, you’re paying a pretty reasonable price considering that you often get more than just coffee beans.

If you’re not much of a coffee addict and don’t drink it very frequently, a coffee subscription might not be the smartest choice for your wallet. Buying a small bag of whole beans or pre-ground coffee from the grocery store every once in a while is probably your best bet.

Coffee Roast and Taste Preferences

Your coffee preference is the most important factor to consider before signing up for a coffee subscription like MistoBox.

Think about the roast type (light roast, medium roast, or dark roast) and flavor profile (chocolatey, fruity, nutty, earthy, etc.) you typically like your beans to have. You might even want to think about how the beans were processed before they were sent to your doorstep. Were they washed or unwashed? Did coffee growers use organic methods? Decide what’s important to you and find out if the subscription service you’re considering has a selection of coffees that fits the bill.

Save 25% On Your First Order – just use code “MBROASTY25” at checkout for any new subscription.  – Click here to get started

Is MistoBox Right for You?

We can’t answer that. But if you’re asking for our two cents — and we’re assuming you are, since you’re reading our full MistoBox coffee subscription review — we think it might be a worthwhile investment for you. But there’s one important caveat: you need to be a frequent coffee drinker who likes brewing at home.

If that’s you, MistoBox could save you money in the long run, plus give you access to artisan coffees you might not have tried otherwise.

Happy Caffeinating!

Mistobox Coffee Review: A High-Quality Subscription Service
Mistobox Coffee Review

Discover the essence of this service through our insightful Mistobox Coffee review capturing its flavors, quality, and artisan coffee choices.

Product In-Stock: InStock

Editor's Rating:
Share the goods

Recommended Reads

Brew like a Barista
from home

The Home Barista Coffee Course 14-lesson video course about brewing consistently amazing coffee at home. Stream or download the entire course to learn how to make coffee as good as your local barista for a fraction of the cost.

Learn more