It’s that time of year again! The outside temperature is dropping, the leaves are changing, and everyone whose favorite drink involves pumpkin spice lets out a triumphant cheer.
It can be a journey to discover which seasonal, sweet-spiced pumpkin spice coffee products best suit your taste buds.
But don’t worry! We’ve done all the research for you and compiled a list of some of the best, most flavorful pumpkin coffee beans to brew this fall!
At A Glance: Best Pumpkin Spice Coffees
Quick Summary: The Best Pumpkin Spice Coffees
|Lifeboost Pumpkin Spice Coffee||Check On Lifeboost→|
|Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Flavored Coffee||Check on Amazon →|
|No products found.||Dunkin' Donuts Pumpkin Spice Coffee||Check on Amazon →|
|Death Wish Pumpkin Spice Coffee||Check on Amazon →|
|Volcanica Pumpkin Spice Coffee||Check on Amazon →|
|Guru Coffee Company Pumpkin Spice Delight Coffee||Check on Amazon →|
|Eight O’Clock Pumpkin Spice Ground Coffee||Check on Amazon →|
|La Colombe Draft Pumpkin Spice Latte||Check on Amazon →|
|Jordan's Skinny Pumpkin Spice Syrup||Check on Amazon →|
|Torani Pumpkin Spice Syrup||Check on Amazon →|
|McCormick Pumpkin Pie Spice||Check on Amazon →|
The Pumpkin Spice Story
You may be wondering where the obsession with pumpkin spice-flavored coffee drinks came from in the first place. Well, the origins can be traced to a mass-marketing plot by the company that popularized the flavor. You’ve probably heard of this brand a time or two — Starbucks Coffee.
In 2003, as Starbucks began advertising a selection of holiday drinks, pumpkin spice emerged victorious as one of the most enjoyed flavors, joining the ranks of chocolate and caramel. After experimenting with and testing ingredients, the classic Pumpkin Spice Latte was born, and once it hit the market, the delicious coffee drink’s popularity skyrocketed.
As time went on, Starbucks altered the PSL’s recipe. The drink originally contained no pumpkin, just a combination of well-balanced spices, sugars, and artificial flavorings. In 2015, however, the company decided to remove the artificial ingredients from the drink and replace them with real pumpkin puree.
Since Starbucks launched the PSL in the early 2000s, many local coffee shops have followed the company’s lead by creating pumpkin spice drinks of their own. The fall’s favorite beverage has also fueled the creation of coffee beans roasted with pumpkin-spiced flavors.
Roasty Rankings: Our Picks for Best Pumpkin Spice Coffees
Though pumpkin spice lovers proudly declare the PSL the king of seasonal drinks, the rawest, most natural way to add hints of pumpkin spice sweetness to your coffee is through beans that have been roasted in the presence of real pumpkin flavor.
There are many benefits to enjoying coffee that was roasted with pumpkin flavors rather than purchasing already-brewed coffee with pumpkin flavoring added to it after the fact.
First of all, the added zest of pumpkin in the roasted coffee creates a bold yet not overpowering taste in your cup. Plus, the authentic aroma soaks through the entire coffee bean, unlike the more concentrated pumpkin extract that’s added to already-brewed coffee.
Now, without further ado, let us introduce you to some of the best pumpkin spice coffee beans!
With one of these products on your countertop, you can fire up your coffee maker and brew pumpkin-flavored goodness any season of the year.
Lifeboost Pumpkin Spice Coffee
Lifeboost Organic Pumpkin Spice Coffee
Your favorite memory of crisp, cool fall weather combined with the finest gourmet beans you’ll ever taste! Lifeboost Premium Pumpkin Spice Coffee comes from coffee beans that have been individually hand selected as the premium bean(s) of a harvest.
Cultivated with extreme care, Lifeboost’s Pumpkin Spice Coffee is our all-time favorite when it comes to overall quality, consistency, and flavor.
This single-origin medium roast coffee is garnished with pumpkin, cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove to create a cup of autumnal perfection.
This 100 percent arabica coffee is some of the best small-batch roasted Joe on the market, and its sweet, delectable flavor is crafted long before the roasting process begins.
Each coffee plant is grown in the rich soil on Nicaragua’s mountainsides, and all the beans are handpicked and selected before being roasted, ensuring only the healthiest, most succulent ones make it into your cup of coffee.
Lifeboost also promises all of its coffee is 100 percent mycotoxin-free. Mycotoxins, or tiny metabolites that can contaminate green coffee beans and are created by certain molds, can cause serious health issues like hypertension, kidney failure, cardiomyopathy, and even cancer.
That’s why it’s such a big deal that Lifeboost goes the extra mile to remove impurities from your beans, promising you a bag of carefully grown, intricately roasted, delicious, fresh, and high-quality coffee.
Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Flavored Coffee
The one and only. The original. The Godfather of all pumpkin spice coffees. Meet Starbucks’ pumpkin spice-flavored ground coffee.
The company’s beans have cozy, comforting flavors like cinnamon and nutmeg that perfectly complement the pumpkin flavor. The already strong pumpkin spice blend can be enjoyed black or with milk, creamer, or sugar.
Roasted with raw, natural flavors, Starbucks’ pumpkin spice coffee is made by blending beans with other natural ingredients.
The pumpkin spice roasted coffee is much higher quality than its latte counterpart since the flavors are more evenly balanced; they won’t overwhelm you as much as the obscene amounts of syrup, sugar, whipped cream, and milk that accompany the PSL.
Dunkin’ Donuts Pumpkin Spice Coffee
No products found.
Since it’s a perfect blend of pumpkin, nutmeg, and cinnamon, Dunkin’s pumpkin spice K-Cups are some of the best on the market.
Coffee lovers who are always running the roads will think Dunkin’ is an excellent option for brewing in your Keurig K-Cup brewer when you need a cup full of autumnal flavor quickly.
Though some coffee drinkers love grinding their own whole bean coffee, Dunkin’ saves you some time by pre-grinding and pre-packaging this delightful blend.
Death Wish Pumpkin Spice Coffee
Craving an organic AND gourmet coffee experience? Go for Death Wish. This brand has captivated coffee lovers’ tastebuds since it first entered the coffee scene. Plus, you can choose between whole bean and pre-ground coffee depending on what works best for you.
Death Wish roasts its cauldron-aged (doesn’t that sound so interesting?) coffee with a chai-inspired combo of cloves, cinnamon, chai, and pumpkin extract.
Distinguishing Death Wish even more, is the method in which the coffee is crafted. Before the roasting process even begins, these 100 percent arabica beans are aged in the spice mixture for 10 days.
Furthermore, the good folks at Death Wish amplify this Joe’s pumpkin flavor with essential oils, and if you pay attention as you sip, you’ll notice a hint of cardamom that adds sweet, spicy tones to your brew.
So, if it’s bold coffee flavor and a pretty hefty caffeine punch you’re after, Death Wish has everything your pumpkin spice-obsessed heart desires.
Volcanica Pumpkin Spice Coffee
When you want notes of pumpkin in your coffee all year long, Volcanica Coffee’s pumpkin spice medium roast is perfect for concocting a light, mellow cup reminiscent of a quiet fall morning…even if it’s the middle of July.
Order your beans in whole bean form or pick from one of three pre-ground options — drip coffee, French press, and espresso — depending on your brewing method of choice.
We love this batch of beans because it doesn’t have a super-strong pumpkin spice flavor. It also boasts more of a pumpkin pie flavor, a satisfying switch-up from the standard pumpkin spice palate.
Moreover, Volcanica makes sure to small-batch roast each load of beans before securely packaging them in an airtight bag and shipping them to your front door.
This means you’ll get the freshest coffee possible and enjoy every single ounce of flavor fully.
Guru Coffee Company Pumpkin Spice Delight Coffee
Crazy for Colombian coffee beans? Give Guru Coffee Company’s pumpkin spice Joe a try.
This light roast is slow-roasted to pumpkin-flavored perfection, but that’s not even the best part: there aren’t any chemicals added to this coffee, just natural pumpkin flavor!
Just as its name implies, this coffee is a delight. It’s got a smooth taste, low acidity levels, and just enough caffeine to get you through the day.
Every bag of beans is small-batch roasted, nitrogen-flushed, and immediately sealed after roasting, so you can rest assured that you’ll be using only the freshest coffee possible to get your pumpkin spice coffee fix.
Eight O’Clock Pumpkin Spice Ground Coffee
Don’t settle for one of those coffee brands that only sells pumpkin spice coffee for a limited time when Eight O’Clock Coffee’s batch of arabica coffee beans is available all the time!
This brew’s aroma is marked by a blend of pumpkin spice and sweet cream, and its flavors — cinnamon spice, maple brown sugar, and pumpkin, obviously — will remind you of your grandma’s homemade pumpkin pie (assuming your grandma is a good baker, of course).
This medium roast is smooth and full-bodied, and like the rest of Eight O’Clock’s product lineup, it’s “rooted in responsibility.” That means the brand supports organizations that support coffee farmers and their communities.
It tastes good and does good — it doesn’t get any better than that.
Other Pumpkin Spice Coffee Choices
Already have a favorite type of coffee and are unwilling to budge and try new beans? That’s okay. There are a couple of other options for spiking your cup of coffee with pumpkin spice-flavored goodness.
Here are a few tricks to try if you need some extra pumpkin flavor in your life.
La Colombe Draft Pumpkin Spice Latte
Have a PSL sans a trip to Starbucks by trying La Colombe’s Pumpkin Spice Latte
This can of cold brew is not only enhanced by nitrous-infused milk and real pumpkin puree, but it also has all sorts of healthy nutrients added, too.
Plus, each can of the non-GMO, lactose- and gluten-free drink only has 100 calories, making it a solid choice for a health-conscious coffee drinker who wants to enjoy sip after sip of perfect fall flavors.
Jordan’s Skinny Pumpkin Spice Syrup
Adding a few splashes of syrup is an easy way to create flavorful, coffee shop-worthy pumpkin spice coffee.
Unfortunately, though, many sweeteners are packed with all the things health-conscious coffee drinkers try to avoid. Sure, they make your beverage taste delicious, but they sort of wreck your diet.
That’s where Jordan’s Skinny Syrups comes in. The brand has concocted a sugar-, calorie-, and gluten-free sweetener packed with pumpkin flavor. Jordan’s Pumpkin Spice Syrup is a lovely addition to any cozy fall coffee drink, from a latte to a cafe au lait.
Made with hints of nutmeg, cloves, and cinnamon, this sweet and succulent syrup leaves you craving more with every sip.
Torani Pumpkin Spice Syrup
Torani Pumpkin Spice Syrup is another means of enhancing your morning coffee. You may have seen a bottle of this stuff in your favorite local coffeehouse; it’s a popular pick for good reason.
This robust sweetener can impress even the most serious java snobs, thanks to notes of cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, and cloves.
Just a drizzle of this stuff can turn your drip coffee or latte into a perfect autumn treat.
McCormick Pumpkin Pie Spice
Now, most of the alternatives to using pumpkin spice-infused beans involve adding the flavor to the coffee after it’s brewed.
Using a jar of McCormick Pumpkin Pie Spice, however, lets you add a bit of autumn flair to your grounds before you hit your coffee maker’s brew button.
McCormick’s blend of cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, and allspice has been a fall favorite since its debut in 1934, and sprinkling a bit of it into your coffee grounds before you brew is a quick and easy way to spice up your cup (literally).
Plus, this is a relatively cheap way to test the waters and make sure you actually like pumpkin spice before splurging on one of the more expensive options out there.
Pumpkin Spice Creamer
Last but certainly not least is pumpkin spice creamer. When the autumn months roll around, your local grocery store will probably have a pretty extensive selection of creamers for you to choose from. So, no matter what you require — non-dairy, sugar-free, etc. — it won’t be hard to find a pumpkin-flavored creamer that works for you.
If you find yourself thinking about this seasonal creamer during spring, summer, or winter, however, check out our creamer recipe roundup and learn how you can make your own batch of the stuff in minutes.
Things To Consider When Choosing Your Brew
Not all pumpkin spice-flavored coffee is the same. To find the best batch of beans possible, keep these qualities in mind.
This one is kind of a no-brainer because it’s always important to think about how much something costs before putting your money where your mouth is.
The price will fluctuate depending on the kind of pumpkin spice coffee you buy (single-origin vs. blend of coffee beans; whether it’s a K-Cup, whole bean, or pre-ground version; etc.) and the quality of the beans used to make it.
The ingredients used to flavor the coffee and whether they’re artificial or authentic may also play a role in how high Joe’s cost is.
Flavoring: Artificial or Authentic?
And since we’re talking about ingredients used to produce the flavorful coffee many of us have come to love over the years, you should consider whether or not you’re buying a naturally or artificially flavored product.
To accommodate those with smaller budgets, artificially flavored beans may be the best choice. However, those who are willing to shell out the extra cash and want a more natural, healthy-tasting brew should probably find something made with authentic pumpkin flavoring.
There are pros and cons to each, so ultimately, the choice depends on which would best suit your palate.
As is the case with all flavored coffees, the flavors in pumpkin spice-infused beans may fluctuate in potency depending on things like brand and roast level.
Consider whether or not you prefer a strong amount of added flavor or just a hint before you buy anything; if you accidentally get something too strong, it might be difficult to dilute its potency.
What Other Fall Flavors are There?
Believe it or not, some people aren’t exactly convinced that pumpkin spice coffee is the must-have treat of the fall. So, what do you do if, after trying the beans in our buying guide, you find yourself in the anti-pumpkin spice camp?
You try one of the other swoon-worthy fall coffee flavors out there, of course!
Caramel apple, hazelnut, and maple-flavored syrups are just a few tools people use to make their normal coffee more appropriate for the autumn months.
For more brewing ideas, check out our fall-flavored coffee drink recipe roundup here.
There are plenty of pumpkin spice options for you to choose from, but only a few make the cut, in our opinion. And since every coffee lover’s tastes are different, there will probably only be one or two of our favorites that please your taste buds.
So, how do you figure out what works for you? Start sampling some beans! Life’s too short to settle for Joe with a mediocre flavor profile, so have fun experimenting with coffee until you find your match made in pumpkin spice heaven.