Buying Guides

The 9 Best Organic K-Cups For Keurigs

Just so you know, if you click on a product on and decide to buy it, we may earn a small commission.

If you enjoy a healthy cup of coffee but don’t enjoy the hustle and bustle of brewing a lot of it at once, you’ve probably considered purchasing a single-serve Keurig machine. And if you enjoy Keurigs, it’s likely because they’re efficient, easy to operate and make delicious coffee. However, not all cups of coffee are made the same.

We here at Roasty understand that balancing a healthy diet with a busy schedule is no easy task. If you’re trying to keep an eye on how healthy your coffee beans are, but also don’t want to change your Keurig single-serve brewing method, organic K-Cups are a great solution for you!

At A Glance: Best Organic K-Cups For Keurigs

What Exactly IS Organic Coffee?

Organic coffee isn’t just your regular old coffee. In fact, the hands that make organic coffee are often more careful and dedicated to the cultivation process. Those who plant, grow, and roast organic coffee do so because they are focused on the quality of the beans instead of the number of products they can produce.

The key characteristic that sets organic coffee apart is that it isn’t tainted by outside synthetic chemicals used in the production/cultivation process. Simply stated: this means the plants are grown with clean and chemical-free soil, air, and water.

Like Free Coffee? Get your first bag free with an Atlas Coffee World Tour Click here to get the deal

Quick Summary: Best Organic K-Cups For Keurigs

  • Delicious And Immune-Boosting
  • Low-Acid Healthy Coffee
  • Single Serve Coffee Pods
Check On Lifeboost→
  • 25% More Coffee
  • Bold Without Bitterness
  • Extra Caffeine Boost
Death Wish Coffee Single Serve Pods - Extra Kick of Caffeine - Dark Roast Coffee Pods - Made with USDA Certified Organic, Fair Trade, Arabica and Robusta Beans (10 Count)DEATH WISH DARK ROAST K-CUPS
  • USDA Certified Organic
  • World’s Strongest Coffee
  • Bold Flavor
Check on Amazon →
Newman's Own Organics Special Blend, Single-Serve Keurig K-Cup Pods, Medium Roast Coffee, 96 CountNEWMAN’S OWN ORGANIC K-CUPS
  • USDA Certified Organic And Fair Trade Certified
  • Compatible With Keurig K-Cup Pod Single-Serve Coffee Makers
  • Simple, Delicious And Recyclable
Check on Amazon →
Real Good Coffee Company - Single Use Coffee Pods - Organic Dark Roast Coffee - K-Cup Compatible including Keurig 2.0 Brewers - Recyclable Cups and Packaging - 36 CountREAL GOOD COFFEE CO ORGANIC K-CUPS
  • Recyclable Coffee Pods
  • Bell Pepper, Cedar, And A Lemony Acidity Flavors
  • Organic Coffee Pods
Check on Amazon →
Organic Coffee Co. OneCUP Java Love 80 Count (Pack of 1) Medium Light Roast Compostable Coffee Pods, K Cup Compatible including Keurig 2.0ORGANIC COFFEE–JAVA LOVE
  • Quality Coffee
  • Eco-Friendly, Commercially Compostable
  • Milk Chocolate, Cinnamon, And Carmelized Spices Flavors
Check on Amazon →
  • Fair Trade Certified And USDA Organic
  • Bold, Complex
  • Dark Roast
Check on Amazon →
Peet's Coffee, Dark Roast K-Cup Pods for Keurig Brewers - Organic Alma de la Tierra, USDA Organic 10 Count (1 Box of 10 K-Cup Pods) Packaging May VaryPEET’S COFFEE ORGANIC ALMA DE LA TIERRA DARK ROAST K-CUPS
  • Organic Alma De La Tierra
  • Recyclable K-Cup Pods
  • Compatible With All Keurig K-Cup Brewers
Check on Amazon →
Peak Performance Organic Decaf Coffee Pods - High Altitude USDA Organic Decaf Coffee. High Mental Performance Coffee. Fair Trade, Low Acid Beans Medium Roast Single Serve Decaffeinated. 24 Count CupsPEAK PERFORMANCE DECAF ROAST K-CUPS
  • High Mental Performance Coffee
  • Healthy Coffee
  • USDA Certified Organic
Check on Amazon →

Why Go Organic?

The coffee industry is a large, ever-growing, and expanding entity that, as most businesses do, depends on producing as much coffee as possible to satisfy thirsty customers–all at the fastest rate possible. To increase efficiency and cut corners, many large scale coffee production companies heavily rely on the usage of chemically based fertilizers and pesticides to help coffee beans grow faster, larger, or in climates that may not be as ideal. However, through the strategy of producing a large quantity of coffee, upholding the quality of that coffee tends to slip through the cracks.

Though going organic reduces the number of potential chemicals and toxins in your coffee, it can also increase the overall flavor quality of the beans too. In fact, some coffee connoisseurs swear up and down that organic coffee possesses and retains more flavor during the cultivation process and after the roasting process. A key explanation is that without the added use of foreign chemicals, the natural enzymes and amino acids in the beans are allowed to grow in flavor and potency.

The Top 9 Organic K-Cups

Organic coffee has spiked in popularity over the last several years due to the overall health benefits that it provides, and it’s taken over the coffee world by storm. With so many coffee companies and roasters claiming to offer the highest quality organic coffee–it can sometimes be difficult to separate the good coffee from the mediocre.

That’s why we’ve done it for you! From the overwhelming about of coffee claiming to be organic, that’s available to purchase, we’ve compiled a list of the most flavor-filled, affordable, best organic coffee K-Cups for you to begin brewing with.

Lifeboost Medium Roast K-Cups

Lifeboost Medium Roast K-Cups
Lifeboost Medium Roast K-Cups
Our rating:

The Non-GMO, single-origin, USDA-certified organic Low-Acid Healthy Coffee is shade-grown & sun-dried high in the mountains of Central America, and is delicious, immune-boosting.


We’ve reviewed many of Lifeboost’s products ourselves, and we’ve been VERY impressed with every single roast that Lifeboost has to offer. Where Lifeboost’s Medium Roast Coffee Pods are concerned–they don’t disappoint! These shade-grown and sun-dried Central American beans have yet to unimpressed us–as well as the multitude of customers who love Lifeboost’s coffee. All of Lifeboost’s beans are USDA certified organic, non-GMO, single-origin beans–but Lifeboost doesn’t stop there.

In fact, Lifeboost actually tests the coffee at the cultivation site to ensure that no mutated or chemically-tainted beans slip into the roasting phase. Lifeboost has a team of individuals that test the ph levels of the coffee, and the beans have been proven to be 27.7% less acidic than some of the company’s leading roasting competitors. Therefore, not only is the coffee some of the healthiest that money can buy, but Lifeboost actually packages their K-Cup coffee in compostable pods!

Wandering Bear Organic K-Cups

wandering bear coffee review
Wandering Bear Dark Roast K-Cups
Our rating:

With a little extra boost of caffeine packed in and the slightly sweet flavor, these organic dark roast K-cups are hard to beat.

Get The Best Price

As we shared in our full review of Wandering Bear, we’re big fans on their dark roast, organic k-cups.

(The cold brew isn’t half bad either…)

These particular K-cups stood out to us because of their bold flavor, with no bitter aftertaste dragging it down. The Wandering Bear dark roast has hints of sweet chocolate and hints of caramel that make for a sweeter cup of coffee – no flavored creamers needed.

These K-Cups are also extra caffeinated because Wandering Bear packs in 25% extra coffee to deliver 250 mg of caffeine in each fully-brewed K-Cup. So if you like that little extra shot in the arm, you should check these out

Death Wish Dark Roast K-Cups

Claiming to be one of the strongest roasted coffees on the market,  Death Wish roasts their Dark Roast K-Cups enough to really highlight and enhance the bold, rich, smokey flavors within the beans. You can expect a full-bodied brew, as well as hints of chocolate and cherry in this sinfully savory blend.

When it comes to caffeine content, Death Wish packs quite a punch of caffeine to fuel you through your mornings. Not only is it USDA certified organic full of delicious flavor, but it also packs quite a punch of caffeine to help fuel you throughout your mornings. Death Wish’s Dark K-Cups are USDA certified organic and are compatible with a multitude of single-serve machines like the Keurig 1.0, Keurig 2.0, Breville, Cuisinart, and some Mr. Coffee Machines.

Newman’s Own Organic K-Cups

Newman’s Own has several different full-bag and K-Cup options that are all USDA organic, but Newman’s Own Organic K-Cups are some of the best quality K-Cups to brew with. Newman’s Special Blend is a medium roast that is well-balanced with a mild acidity, making it both savory and soothing to sip on. A large contributing factor to the savory taste of Newman’s is the high altitude climate the beans are grown in, as well as the careful cultivation of arabica coffee beans used for this roast.

Little known to some, Newman’s Own actually donates 100% of its profits to charity after all business expenses are paid for. So not only can you enjoy a delicious cup of coffee from Newman’s, but you can feel good about it too!

Real Good Coffee Co Organic K-Cups

A dark roast coffee, Real Good Coffee has a rich, full-body, and is exactly as its name implies. With natural, clean flavors like bell-pepper, cedar, and zesty lemon, Real Good Coffee’s Organic K-Cups are rich in flavor and bright in acidity. This extra bold brew can be enjoyed black, or with sweeter and lighter sweetness and creamers to help balance out the tangy, fruity flavors.

Based out of Seattle, Washington, Real Good Coffee consists of a small, like-minded group of coffee enthusiasts who have been sourcing, roasting, and crafting coffee for over 30 years. Though the company sells whole bags of coffee, Nespresso Pods, and Keurig K-cups–the K-cups are one of the highest selling products. Holding the quality of their coffee to the utmost importance, Real Good Coffee also does their part to protect the environment–selling every pack of K-Cups in 100% recyclable pods.

Organic Coffee–Java Love

If you love flavors like milk chocolate, caramel, spices, and cinnamon, then look no further than the Java Love Roast by The Organic Coffee Company. These organic K-Cups are a medium-light blend, filled with caffeine yet embodying an acidity that isn’t overwhelming or overpowering. Sourcing the beans for this roast from Central America, Organic Coffee ensures that all of its beans meet standard USDA requirements.

Organic Coffee only uses 100% arabica coffee, giving you the delicious, ripe amount of flavor but still enough caffeine to get you through the day. We particularly enjoy Organic’s K-Cups because not only are the beans roasted as carefully as possible, but the lighter roast level provides a refreshing taste and feel in comparison to other darkly-roasted organic coffees.

Green Mountain Sumatran Reserve Organic K-Cups

No products found.

The king of Keurig machines, Green Mountain Coffee has been cultivating and creating coffee to specifically complement their Keurig machines. Green Mountain Coffee has been crafting the best K-Cups on the market because the company actually merged with Keurig in 2014, and then with Dr. Pepper Snapple Group in 2018. Since the company already manufactures Keurigs themselves, their K-Cups are some of the most well-designed and compatible with single-serve machines.

This fair trade organic Sumatran Reserve is a darker single-origin roast that is filled with unique flavor combinations like brown sugar and warm spices to give you a comforting, savory brew to enjoy in the morning. In fact, this roast is so delectable, that it’s delicious enough for you to drink black if you prefer.

Peet’s Coffee Organic Alma De La Tierra Dark Roast K-Cups

“Alma De La Terra” means “The Soul of The Earth” in Spanish, and this roast tastes just as magical as its name sounds. Made with arabica beans grown at a high elevation deep in the mountains of Latin America, Peet’s Coffee roasts these beans to perfection, making sure to preserve the flavors of citrus and sweet dark chocolate.

Peet’s takes special care to roast their coffee beans in small batches to closely monitor the roasting process. This dedication helps to ensure that they are roasted evenly and thoroughly–but without burning or over-roasting them.

Peak Performance Decaf Roast K-Cups

Love coffee but hate the caffeine? Peak Performance’s Decaf Roast K-Cups have combined delicious coffee flavor, the convenience of a single-serve brewing method, as well as the high quality traits of rich organic arabica coffee. The side effects of caffeine can take a toll on coffee drinkers in general, but to eliminate the irritating, anxiety-causing effects, Peak gives you rich, delicious organic coffee that you can enjoy at any time of day.

A medium roast, this special blend is one that’s well balanced, full of flavor, and makes a great option even for those who enjoy caffeine in their coffee. Take it from us: if you’re interested in experimenting with Peak Performance coffee, your taste buds will definitely thank you.

The Verdict

There are SO many benefits of organic coffee–not even for your health, but for the environment and the manual workers in the coffee industry too. Even still: a Keurig-compatible, chemically-free, clean cup of coffee never hurt anyone. However, before you begin buying and trying different organic coffees, it’s important to do your research to make sure that the coffee is made through completely organic methods.

The first step is verifying that the coffee is certified organic through USDA standards. The coffee itself should have some sort of label(s) to help identify certain characteristics about the organic components of the quality of the coffee. After that, all you’ll need to decide is what roast/blend fits your taste buds the best, and how many K-Cups you need in a pack!

Enjoy experimenting with organic K-Cups, and as always:

Happy caffeinating!

Share the goods

Recommended Reads

  • Buying Guides

    Keurig Vue vs. K Cup

    Check out our comparison of the Keurig Vue vs. K Cup to help you decide which is a better fit for your kitchen counter!

  • Buying Guides

    Seattle’s Best vs. Starbucks Coffee

    Which company makes a better cup of coffee? Read our Seattle's Best vs Starbucks comparison to find out their pros and cons!

  • Coffee Facts

    Ninja Coffee Bar vs Keurig: Pod or Pass?

    Are you a mad scientist with a need for range or a busy bee with a need for speed? We've put together this guide on Ninja Coffee Bar vs Keurig to help you find the right machine for you.

  • Buying Guides

    The 6 Best Coffee Samplers

    Looking for a little variety in your life? Here are some of the best coffee samplers that'll give you the different brews you need!

  • Coffee Facts

    Dutch Bros vs. Starbucks

    Dutch Bros and Starbucks offer all the features of high-quality coffee and signature drinks but is there an overall winner between the two?

  • Coffee Facts

    Zimbabwe Coffee

    Zimbabwe coffee isn't one that's very well-known around the world, but its wine-like acidity is very similar to that of its Kenyan counterpart.

Brew like a Barista
from home

The Home Barista Coffee Course 14-lesson video course about brewing consistently amazing coffee at home. Stream or download the entire course to learn how to make coffee as good as your local barista for a fraction of the cost.

Learn more