How to Brew

10 Ways to Add Extra Flavor To Your Coffee

Just so you know, if you click on a product on RoastyCoffee.com and decide to buy it, we may earn a small commission.

We all love black coffee, and many of us even love coffee with various sweeteners and creamers. But have you ever tried to expand your horizons by adding other flavors and spices?

10 Ways to Add Extra Flavor To Your Coffee

Today let’s examine 10 ways to add extra flavor to your coffee so you can discover even more interesting and exotic coffee combinations that will delight your taste buds and keep you coming back for more. I have no doubt that after reading this list, you will be heading home to give at least one or more of these a try.

10 Ways to Spice Things Up

Vanilla Extract

If you love the creamy taste that coffee creams and sugar add to your coffee, but aren’t a fan of those added calories, then this is the easiest way to get the best of both worlds. Remember, though, a little goes a long way.

Add one bean to your coffee grounds during the brewing process for best results. Remember, the longer the bean is mixed with the grounds the stronger the vanilla flavor will be. If you don’t have beans handy, just add two or three drops to your pot or even one small drop to your cup.

If you’re buying vanilla extract, make sure you get the real stuff (no imitation flavoring). Something like this will work great:

Cinnamon

Cinnamon is one of the easiest ways to really spice up that cup of joe in the mornings. This spice actually comes from the bark of an evergreen tree known as the Cinnamomum tree.

This spice also has one of the highest antioxidant contents of any spice on this planet, and it has even been shown to boost your immune system. Did I mention it also tastes great!

Add a cinnamon stick to your pot when you brew your coffee so the hot coffee will extract all that wonderful flavor or simply add a dash to a single cup. You can get it as sticks or ground here:

Cardamom

This spice is commonly used in the Middle East with coffee, but is lesser known in the west. This spice has a flavor that is exotic and similar to ginger, so it will really give you a unique coffee taste when used properly.

It also has many health benefits. Cardamom is loaded with fiber and other essential minerals and has been shown to improve your circulation.

To use it, just sprinkle a pinch or two into a freshly brewed cup of coffee or add a few whole cardamom seeds to your beans before you grind them for brewing.

Nutmeg

If you prefer a hint of earthiness to your morning brew, then you may want to consider nutmeg. Overall, the taste is slightly sweet which will delight your earthy taste buds. However, it does far more in the smell arena, giving your coffee a slightly sweet smell that is truly unique and one that should be enjoyed by all.

This one is more difficult to measure, and should be used to taste and smell, of course. A dash is often perfect for a typical cup of coffee, but I encourage you to experiment to find the right mixture for your senses. You can even buy it Fair Trade here:

Cocoa Nibs

Why didn’t I just say chocolate? That’s because chocolate is something different. Cocoa Nibs are what chocolate is before you process it into those delicious candy bars that all of us love.

However, their texture is quite different. They taste much like dark chocolate, but with a nuttier and slightly chewier texture. Of course, in my opinion, they truly shine in a good cup of coffee.

Add about ½ of a teaspoon for every two cups of coffee into your coffee grinder along with your beans, and you will extract a cocoa goodness in your coffee that any chocolate lover will crave.

Interested? Check out these roasted, sustainably sourced nibs:

No products found.

Ginger

I mentioned ginger earlier, as cardamom is very similar. Still, if you don’t want to try to find cardamom, then you could always give ginger a try.

If you love gingerbread, then you will love it in your coffee. This is even a great treat to transform your coffee into a unique, seasonal drink.

Try adding a few slices of ginger to your coffee grounds before you brew. If you don’t have fresh ginger, one or two tablespoons of ginger powder should do just fine. Get some here:

Lavender

Another great spice to give your coffee a more springtime seasonal twist, adding lavender to your coffee can transform it and give it a very floral taste. This spice tends to lend itself better to bright, citrus brews instead of the stronger, darker coffees.

Sprinkle a little dried lavender into your grinding mechanism and then add your coffee. Be careful not to add too much. If you do, your coffee will taste more soapy than springy. Give it a try with these dried flowers:

Star Anise

Now this one may not be for everyone. Do you like liquorice? If so, then this may just be perfect for you. When blended with high quality beans, the flavor that star anise adds to your coffee is truly unique.

Just don’t overdo it. A half a pod is more than enough for a single cup of coffee. If you add too much, the liquorice-like flavor will overpower your coffee no matter how strong you like your morning cup of joe.

I suggest experimenting with this one a little to find the perfect balance for your tastes. If you aren’t a liquorice fan, I would still at least give it a try, as it may surprise you. You can get it here:

Clove

Another common household spice, this one seems tailored made for coffee. A flavor combo that reaches back decades, adding cloves to your coffee gives it a very musky, classic, leather couch vibe.

If you buy the spice whole (which you should for the sake of freshness), you can just use your handy coffee grinder before putting it into your grounds.

To prepare your coffee, toss in a few cloves into the grounds and brew your coffee. If you are making a single cup, reduce the amount of clove you use, so it doesn’t taste too strong. Here’s where you can find some whole:

Peppermint Oil

Nothing screams ‘tis the season more than peppermint coffee. But you don’t have to go to your local coffee shop in order to enjoy this tasty holiday treat.

Peppermint is an herb that has been crossed with spearmint and water mint, and is a favorite flavor of many in the world. But for your coffee, you will be using peppermint oil extract.

To prepare it, add a few drops to your pot during the brewing process. Use it sparingly, though, as peppermint can easily overtake any of the other flavors of your coffee no matter how rich your coffee beans are and how great they taste. Try some and find the right balance for you:

Wrapping Up

These are only ten of our favorite ways to add extra flavor to coffee, but the list could go on and on. I encourage you to experiment with different spices and test your results to see what kind of spices you enjoy adding to your coffee.

At the end of the day I think you will find it to be both fun and rewarding to try new things with your coffee and expand your coffee taste horizons.

What flavors do you like to add to your coffee? Tell us about them in the comments below as we would love to hear what spices you use in your coffee to really add extra flavor and even more enjoyment out of your morning cup of coffee.

Happy Caffeinating!

Share the goods

Recommended Reads

  • Coffee Facts

    The Complete Guide to Eating Coffee Beans

    Sure, you may love to drink coffee. But have you ever EATEN it? We've got everything you need to know about eating coffee beans right here! Can you eat them? Are they good for you? Here's your complete guide to snacking on coffee beans.

  • Buying Guides

    Driftaway Coffee Review

    Driftaway is one of the most popular coffee subscription services out there, and if you're considering getting a subscription of your own, there are some important things you should know. Make sure to read our review of Driftaway, right here.

  • How to Brew

    Easy Breezy Brown Sugar Latte

    We've all had those days where we just want to curl up inside with a warm drink. This super simple brown sugar latte recipe has got you covered with ingredients that you probably already have on-hand.

  • How to Brew

    11 Decadent Spanish Coffee Recipes To Create Tonight

  • How to Brew

    Hazelnutty Mocha

    Mad for Mochas? So are we, and this hazelnutty mocha does not disappoint! With a sweet hazelnut spread base, this beverage will surely add a little intrigue to your next coffee treat.

  • How to Brew

    Bulletproof Coffee Recipe

    Give your day the boost it needs with bulletproof coffee. This combo of healthy fats and caffeine whips up into a deliciously creamy and smooth cup o’ joe that'll keep your brain in tip-top shape.

Brew like a Barista
from home

The Home Barista Coffee Course 14-lesson video course about brewing consistently amazing coffee at home. Stream or download the entire course to learn how to make coffee as good as your local barista for a fraction of the cost.

Learn more